Analysis of SCJ Lesson 20: “Secrets of Heaven – Figurative Bowl (Container)”

A Refutation Using “Testing Shincheonji’s Claims: Two Lenses, One Story”

---

Introduction: The Potter’s Hands

Imagine visiting a pottery studio where a master craftsman works at his wheel. You watch, fascinated, as he takes a lump of clay and begins shaping it. “This clay,” he explains, “will become whatever I decide it should be. Some pieces are for everyday use—coffee mugs, dinner plates. But others,” he says, lowering his voice with reverence, “are for special purposes. Noble purposes.”

He shows you two finished pieces: a simple bowl and an ornate vase. “See the difference? Both started as the same clay, but one is common and the other is noble. The question is,” he says, turning to you, “which kind of vessel do you want to be?”

The question feels profound. Of course you want to be noble, not common. Who wouldn’t? But then he adds something that makes you uncomfortable: “Most people end up as common vessels. They think they’re being shaped for noble purposes, but they’re actually filled with the wrong things. They’re being molded by the wrong potter.”

He gestures to another craftsman across the room. “That potter over there? He makes vessels that look beautiful on the outside, but they’re flawed on the inside. They crack under pressure. They leak. They’re ultimately worthless.” He leans closer. “The tragedy is, most people don’t realize they’re at the wrong potter’s wheel until it’s too late.”

Now you’re anxious. How do you know which potter is shaping you? How can you be sure you’re becoming a noble vessel and not a common one? The master craftsman smiles. “That’s why you’re here. I can teach you the difference. I can show you how to identify the true Potter and avoid the false one. But you have to trust me completely. You have to let me reshape everything you thought you knew.”

This is what happens in SCJ Lesson 20.

The lesson appears to be a beautiful biblical teaching about God as the Potter who shapes us into vessels for His purposes. The instructor uses familiar passages from Isaiah, Romans, and 2 Timothy to explain how God molds us through His Word and refines us through trials. Everything sounds biblical, encouraging, and spiritually enriching.

But beneath the surface, something else is happening. The lesson is constructing a framework that will eventually position SCJ as the “true Potter” and mainstream Christianity as the “false potter” making flawed vessels. By teaching that most Christians are “common vessels” filled with the wrong things while SCJ members are “noble vessels” being properly shaped, the lesson creates spiritual elitism and anxiety that keeps students dependent on SCJ’s teaching.

This lesson sits at position 20 in the Introductory (Parables) Level—strategically placed after students have learned about “sealed” Scripture, spiritual food and drink, and symbolic interpretation. Students are now being taught about their identity and purpose, with the implicit message that only through SCJ’s teaching can they become the “noble vessels” God intends.

By the time students realize where this teaching leads, they’ve already accepted the framework: that their spiritual value depends on what “fills” them (SCJ’s interpretation), that most Christians are “common vessels” with flawed understanding, that leaving SCJ means becoming “empty” or filled with “Satan’s lies,” and that their entire identity is bound up in being a “noble vessel” shaped by SCJ’s teaching.

Let’s examine how this lesson uses legitimate biblical teaching about God as Potter to create an illegitimate system of spiritual elitism and control, and how the principles in “Testing Shincheonji’s Claims: Two Lenses, One Story” expose the manipulation.

---

Part 1: What SCJ Teaches in This Lesson

The Surface Teaching (What Students Hear)

The lesson presents what appears to be straightforward biblical teaching about believers as vessels:

Physical Characteristics of Bowls:

• Instruments for holding/containing something
• Named and valued based on their contents
• Made by a potter through a process

The Potter’s Process:

1. Clay (dust) = Starting point (humanity)
2. Water = God’s Word shapes us (Deuteronomy 32:2)
3. Fire = Trials refine us (Jeremiah 5:14)
4. Result = Useful vessel for God’s purposes

Spiritual Meaning of Bowl:

• Bowl/Container = A person or person’s heart
• God = The Potter (Isaiah 64:8)
• We = The clay being shaped

Two Types of Vessels:

Noble Vessels (Special Purposes):

• Filled with God’s Word
• Cleansed by Jesus’ words (John 15:3)
• Useful to the Master (2 Timothy 2:20-21)
• Example: Paul, who emptied himself of worldly values to be filled with Christ

Common Vessels (Ordinary Use):

• Filled with “greed and self-indulgence” (Matthew 23:25-26)
• Like the Pharisees—clean outside, dirty inside
• Ultimately worthless “dregs” (Jeremiah 48:11-12)
• Prepared for destruction (Romans 9:22)

The Church as a Large Bowl:

• Many individual vessels gathered together
• Like the parable of the net catching fish (Matthew 13:47-50)
• Good fish kept in baskets (church), bad fish thrown back to sea (world)

Spiritual Fasting:

• Physical fasting = Abstaining from physical food
• Spiritual fasting = Abstaining from “Satan’s lies” and “Satan’s food”
• Based on Isaiah 58:4-6 and John 8:31-32
• Once you know truth, you must “fast from Satan’s food”

The Subtext (What’s Really Being Established)

Beneath this seemingly biblical teaching, several problematic foundations are being laid:

1. Creating Spiritual Hierarchy: The lesson establishes a clear hierarchy: noble vessels (those with SCJ’s teaching) vs. common vessels (those without). This creates elitism where SCJ members see themselves as spiritually superior to other Christians.

2. Redefining Spiritual Value: The lesson teaches that a person’s spiritual value comes from what “fills” them. Since SCJ claims to have the only correct “opened” interpretation, this means only SCJ members are truly valuable “noble vessels.”

3. Preparing for Separation: By comparing mainstream Christians to the Pharisees (clean outside, dirty inside) and to “worthless dregs,” the lesson prepares students to view other Christians as spiritually inferior and ultimately destined for judgment.

4. Creating Dependency: The emphasis on being “filled” and “overflowing” with God’s Word creates anxiety: Am I filled enough? Do I have enough of the Word? This dependency will be resolved by staying in SCJ where students believe they’re being “filled” with truth.

5. Establishing “Us vs. Them” Mentality: The lesson’s framework creates binary categories:

• Noble vs. common
• Filled with God’s Word vs. filled with Satan’s lies
• Inside the basket (church/SCJ) vs. in the sea (world/other churches)
• Fasting from Satan’s food vs. consuming it unknowingly

6. Misusing “Spiritual Fasting”: The concept of “spiritual fasting” (abstaining from “Satan’s food”) will later be used to discourage students from reading other Christian materials, listening to sermons from other pastors, or engaging with theological perspectives outside SCJ.

---

Part 2: Analysis Through “Testing Shincheonji’s Claims: Two Lenses, One Story”

Chapter 21-23: God’s Character and the Heart of the Gospel

Chapter 21 of “Testing Shincheonji’s Claims: Two Lenses, One Story” is titled “The Heart of God: When Love Refuses to Let Go.” This chapter examines whether God’s character is primarily about conditional acceptance (based on performance or correct interpretation) or unconditional love (based on His grace).

The Character Problem in This Lesson:

The lesson presents God’s shaping process in a way that creates anxiety rather than confidence. Students are told they must be “filled” with the right things to be “noble vessels,” and that most Christians are actually “common vessels” or worse—”worthless dregs” destined for judgment.

The lesson states: “A person’s value is not based on outward appearances or possessions. Their value comes from what is inside them—what they contain.”

While this sounds spiritual, it subtly shifts the basis of our value from God’s grace to our performance (how much of “the Word” we’ve acquired through SCJ’s teaching).

Chapter 21’s Biblical Response:

The chapter explains that our value before God is not based on what we contain or achieve, but on His love and Christ’s work:

1. Our value is intrinsic, not performance-based:

• Genesis 1:27: “So God created mankind in his own image, in the image of God he created them”
• Psalm 139:13-14: “For you created my inmost being; you knit me together in my mother’s womb. I praise you because I am fearfully and wonderfully made”

Our value comes from being made in God’s image, not from how much biblical knowledge we’ve acquired.

2. God’s love is unconditional:

• Romans 5:8: “But God demonstrates his own love for us in this: While we were still sinners, Christ died for us.”
• 1 John 4:10: “This is love: not that we loved God, but that he loved us and sent his Son as an atoning sacrifice for our sins.”

God loved us and valued us enough to send Christ while we were still sinners—before we were “filled” with anything good.

3. Our righteousness is in Christ, not in our “contents”:

• 2 Corinthians 5:21: “God made him who had no sin to be sin for us, so that in him we might become the righteousness of God.”
• Philippians 3:9: “…not having a righteousness of my own that comes from the law, but that which is through faith in Christ—the righteousness that comes from God on the basis of faith.”

We are “noble vessels” not because of what we contain, but because of Christ’s righteousness imputed to us.

4. All believers are being shaped by God:

• Philippians 1:6: “…being confident of this, that he who began a good work in you will carry it on to completion until the day of Christ Jesus.”
• Romans 8:29: “For those God foreknew he also predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son”

God is shaping all believers, not just those in one organization. The idea that only SCJ members are “noble vessels” being properly shaped contradicts Scripture’s teaching that God is at work in all His children.

Biblical Response to the “Noble vs. Common” Framework:

The lesson’s division of believers into “noble” and “common” vessels based on what they’re “filled with” (SCJ’s interpretation vs. other teaching) is problematic:

1. The Potter’s Sovereign Choice:

Romans 9:21 (quoted in the lesson) says: “Does not the potter have the right to make out of the same lump of clay some pottery for special purposes and some for common use?”

But context matters. Romans 9 is about God’s sovereign election and His right to show mercy to whom He chooses. Paul is addressing why some Jews rejected Christ while Gentiles believed. The passage is about God’s sovereign grace, not about believers achieving “noble” status through correct interpretation.

Moreover, the very next verses (Romans 9:22-24) clarify:

• Verse 22: “What if God, although choosing to show his wrath and make his power known, bore with great patience the objects of his wrath—prepared for destruction?”
• Verse 23: “What if he did this to make the riches of his glory known to the objects of his mercy, whom he prepared in advance for glory”
• Verse 24: “even us, whom he also called, not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles?”

Paul is contrasting believers (objects of mercy) with unbelievers (objects of wrath), not dividing believers into “noble” and “common” categories based on their level of biblical knowledge.

2. All Believers Are Noble Vessels:

The New Testament consistently teaches that all believers are:

• Royal priesthood: 1 Peter 2:9 – “But you are a chosen people, a royal priesthood, a holy nation, God’s special possession”
• God’s temple: 1 Corinthians 3:16 – “Don’t you know that you yourselves are God’s temple and that God’s Spirit dwells in your midst?”
• Children of God: 1 John 3:1 – “See what great love the Father has lavished on us, that we should be called children of God! And that is what we are!”
• Saints: Ephesians 1:1 – “To God’s holy people in Ephesus, the faithful in Christ Jesus”

There’s no biblical category of “common” believers vs. “noble” believers based on interpretive knowledge. All who are in Christ are holy, set apart, and valued by God.

3. The 2 Timothy 2:20-21 Passage in Context:

The lesson quotes 2 Timothy 2:20-21: “In a large house there are articles not only of gold and silver, but also of wood and clay; some are for special purposes and some for common use. Those who cleanse themselves from the latter will be instruments for special purposes…”

But the context shows this is about personal holiness, not about having correct interpretation:

• 2 Timothy 2:19: “Nevertheless, God’s solid foundation stands firm, sealed with this inscription: ‘The Lord knows those who are his,’ and, ‘Everyone who confesses the name of the Lord must turn away from wickedness.'”
• 2 Timothy 2:22: “Flee the evil desires of youth and pursue righteousness, faith, love and peace, along with those who call on the Lord out of a pure heart.”

Paul is talking about moral purity and turning from wickedness, not about acquiring special interpretive knowledge. The “cleansing” is from sin, not from “wrong interpretation.”

Chapter 11-13: Information Control and Spiritual Fasting

Chapter 11 of “Testing Shincheonji’s Claims” examines isolation strategies disguised as protection. This lesson’s teaching on “spiritual fasting” demonstrates a sophisticated form of information control.

The Information Control in “Spiritual Fasting”:

The lesson teaches: “When someone identifies something as Satan’s food, they should stop receiving it no more. I will now abstain. I will only partake of the truth. That’s spiritual fasting.”

This sounds spiritual, but it’s preparing students to:

1. Reject outside Christian teaching: Any teaching that contradicts SCJ will be labeled “Satan’s food”
2. Isolate from other Christians: Fellowship with non-SCJ Christians becomes “consuming Satan’s food”
3. Avoid critical examination: Reading critiques of SCJ or consulting other sources becomes “eating Satan’s lies”

Chapter 13’s Verification Problem:

Chapter 13 addresses how to evaluate spiritual claims that cannot be independently verified. The “spiritual fasting” concept creates a verification problem: How do students know what is “Satan’s food” vs. “God’s food”?

The lesson provides no objective criteria—only the implicit message that SCJ’s teaching is “God’s food” and everything else is “Satan’s food.” Students are left dependent on SCJ’s categorization.

Biblical Response to “Spiritual Fasting”:

1. The Isaiah 58 passage is about social justice, not information control:

The lesson quotes Isaiah 58:4-6 to support “spiritual fasting,” but context shows this passage is about social justice and authentic worship:

• Isaiah 58:6-7: “Is not this the kind of fasting I have chosen: to loose the chains of injustice and untie the cords of the yoke, to set the oppressed free and break every yoke? Is it not to share your food with the hungry and to provide the poor wanderer with shelter—when you see the naked, to clothe them, and not to turn away from your own flesh and blood?”

God is contrasting empty religious ritual (fasting while oppressing others) with authentic faith that cares for the needy. This has nothing to do with avoiding other Christian teaching.

2. The John 8:31-32 passage is about freedom from sin, not from other teachers:

The lesson quotes John 8:31-32: “If you hold to my teaching, you are really my disciples. Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.”

But the context shows Jesus is talking about freedom from sin:

• John 8:34: “Jesus replied, ‘Very truly I tell you, everyone who sins is a slave to sin.'”
• John 8:36: “So if the Son sets you free, you will be free indeed.”

Jesus is talking about freedom from slavery to sin through knowing Him, not about avoiding other Christian teachers or materials.

3. The Bible encourages testing and examination, not isolation:

• Acts 17:11: “Now the Berean Jews were of more noble character than those in Thessalonica, for they received the message with great eagerness and examined the Scriptures every day to see if what Paul said was true.”
• 1 Thessalonians 5:21: “Test everything; hold fast what is good.”
• 1 John 4:1: “Dear friends, do not believe every spirit, but test the spirits to see whether they are from God”

The Bible encourages examination and testing, not isolation from other perspectives. The Bereans were commended for fact-checking Paul’s teaching, not condemned for it.

4. True spiritual discernment requires multiple counselors:

• Proverbs 11:14: “For lack of guidance a nation falls, but victory is won through many advisers.”
• Proverbs 15:22: “Plans fail for lack of counsel, but with many advisers they succeed.”

The Bible encourages seeking multiple perspectives, not relying solely on one source. The concept of “spiritual fasting” that isolates students from all other Christian input contradicts biblical wisdom.

Chapter 18-20: Testing Authority and Creative Fulfillment

Chapter 18 of “Testing Shincheonji’s Claims” examines how to test claims of spiritual authority. This lesson makes implicit authority claims by positioning SCJ as the “true Potter” shaping “noble vessels.”

The Authority Problem:

The lesson teaches that God shapes us through His Word (true), but then suggests that most Christians are being shaped incorrectly—they’re “common vessels” or “worthless dregs” like the Pharisees. The implicit message: SCJ has the correct “water” (interpretation) that properly shapes believers.

Chapter 19-20’s Response:

Chapter 19 discusses unfalsifiable claims. The lesson’s framework creates an unfalsifiable system:

• If you’re in SCJ → You’re a “noble vessel” being properly shaped
• If you’re outside SCJ → You’re a “common vessel” or “worthless dregs”
• If you question this → You’re resisting being shaped by the “true Potter”

Chapter 20 warns about “creative fulfillment”—adding interpretive layers to Scripture that support predetermined conclusions. This lesson demonstrates that technique through its handling of the “bowl/vessel” metaphor.

Biblical Response to the “True Potter” Claim:

1. The Jeremiah 48:11-12 passage is about judgment on Moab, not on Christians:

The lesson quotes Jeremiah 48:11-12 about Moab being “worthless dregs” and asks: “If it is a prophecy, that means it must have a future fulfillment involving people who were once noble but became like useless vessels filled with worthless things.”

But context shows this is a specific prophecy about the nation of Moab (a pagan nation, enemy of Israel), not a pattern for judging Christians:

• Jeremiah 48:1: “Concerning Moab: This is what the Lord Almighty, the God of Israel, says: ‘Woe to Nebo, for it will be ruined'”
• Jeremiah 48:7: “Since you trust in your deeds and riches, you too will be taken captive”

This is a historical judgment prophecy about a specific pagan nation, not a template for categorizing Christians as “worthless dregs.”

2. The Matthew 23:25-26 passage is about the Pharisees’ hypocrisy, not about Christians with different interpretations:

The lesson applies Jesus’ condemnation of the Pharisees to Christians who don’t have SCJ’s interpretation:

“So Jesus and the 12 disciples judge the Pharisees and teachers of the law with the word. They smashed them, fulfilling the prophecy.”

But the Pharisees were condemned for:

• Hypocrisy: Teaching one thing, living another (Matthew 23:3)
• Adding human traditions: Making God’s Word void through their traditions (Mark 7:8-9, 13)
• Rejecting the Messiah: Refusing to believe despite overwhelming evidence (John 12:37-40)

This is vastly different from sincere Christians who simply interpret some passages differently than SCJ. Applying this condemnation to other Christians is a gross misuse of Scripture.

3. God is the Potter of all believers, not just SCJ members:

• Isaiah 64:8: “Yet you, Lord, are our Father. We are the clay, you are the potter; we are all the work of your hand.”
• Jeremiah 18:6: “‘Like clay in the hand of the potter, so are you in my hand, Israel,’ declares the Lord.”

God is the Potter of all His people, not just those in one organization. The idea that only SCJ members are being properly “shaped” while all other Christians are “common vessels” or “worthless dregs” is spiritual elitism that contradicts Scripture.

Chapter 24-26: The Unified Biblical Narrative

Chapter 24-25 of “Testing Shincheonji’s Claims” (“The Scarlet Thread”) examines the Bible’s unified narrative centered on Christ’s redemptive work. This lesson demonstrates fragmentation by pulling vessel/potter passages from multiple contexts without showing how they all point to the gospel.

The Fragmentation Problem:

The lesson jumps between:

• Isaiah 64:8 (God as Potter)
• Romans 9:21-24 (Potter’s sovereign choice)
• Acts 9:15 (Paul as chosen vessel)
• 2 Timothy 2:20-21 (Noble vs. common vessels)
• Jeremiah 48:11-12 (Judgment on Moab)
• Matthew 23:25-26 (Condemnation of Pharisees)

Each passage is examined to support the “noble vs. common vessels” framework, but the lesson never shows how these passages fit into the Bible’s overarching story of redemption through Christ.

Chapter 26 (“Reading Revelation Like a First-Century Christian”) explains that Revelation’s imagery was meaningful to its original audience. The “seven bowls of wrath” in Revelation 15:7 (the lesson’s main reference) would have been understood as God’s judgment on those persecuting the church, not as a metaphor for how believers are categorized.

Biblical Response:

1. The Bible’s unified message about believers as vessels:

When we read the Bible as a unified story, the vessel/potter theme has a clear progression:

Old Testament: God shapes His people Israel

• Isaiah 64:8: “We are the clay, you are the potter”
• Jeremiah 18:1-6: The potter reshapes marred clay into something useful

New Testament Fulfillment: God shapes all believers through Christ

• 2 Corinthians 4:7: “But we have this treasure in jars of clay to show that this all-surpassing power is from God and not from us”
• Ephesians 2:10: “For we are God’s handiwork, created in Christ Jesus to do good works”

The Unified Message:

• God is the Potter who shapes His people
• We are all “jars of clay”—fragile, ordinary vessels
• Our value comes from the “treasure” inside us—Christ, not from our own excellence
• God shapes us through trials and His Word
• All believers are being conformed to Christ’s image (Romans 8:29)

This is the Bible’s unified teaching about believers as vessels. The lesson isn’t wrong that God shapes us, but it fragments these passages to build an elitist system rather than showing how they all point to God’s grace in shaping ordinary people for His purposes.

2. The “treasure in jars of clay” metaphor:

2 Corinthians 4:7 provides the New Testament’s clearest teaching about believers as vessels:

“But we have this treasure in jars of clay to show that this all-surpassing power is from God and not from us.”

Notice what this passage teaches:

• We are all “jars of clay”: Ordinary, fragile, common vessels
• The treasure is Christ/the gospel: Not our interpretive knowledge
• The purpose: To show that the power is from God, not from us

Paul doesn’t divide believers into “noble jars” and “common jars” based on their knowledge. He says we’re all common jars (clay pots), and our value comes from the treasure (Christ) within us, not from our own excellence.

This directly contradicts SCJ’s teaching that some believers are “noble vessels” (those with SCJ’s interpretation) while others are “common vessels” or “worthless dregs” (those without).

---

Part 3: The Psychological Progression

The Indoctrination Process at Lesson 20

By Lesson 20, students have been in the Parables course for approximately 6-10 weeks. Let’s examine what’s happened psychologically:

1. Identity Formation:

Students have been taught:

• The Bible was “sealed” and most Christians don’t understand it (Lessons 1-10)
• Spiritual food/drink determines spiritual health (Lessons 15-19)
• Now: Your identity is as a “vessel” being shaped—are you noble or common?

Each lesson adds another layer to students’ spiritual identity, increasingly tied to SCJ’s teaching.

2. Elitism and Separation:

The “noble vs. common vessels” framework creates:

• Positive identity: I’m a noble vessel being properly shaped by the true Potter
• Negative comparison: Other Christians are common vessels or worthless dregs
• Separation: I need to stay with those being properly shaped (SCJ)

This elitism makes it psychologically difficult to leave SCJ—doing so would mean becoming a “common vessel” again.

3. Dependency on “Being Filled”:

The emphasis on being “filled” and “overflowing” with God’s Word creates anxiety:

• Am I filled enough?
• Do I have enough of the Word?
• What if I’m only 20% full instead of overflowing?

This anxiety is resolved by staying in SCJ where students believe they’re being “filled” with truth.

4. Fear of “Satan’s Food”:

The “spiritual fasting” concept creates fear of consuming “Satan’s food” (any teaching outside SCJ). Students begin to:

• Avoid reading other Christian books
• Stop listening to sermons from other pastors
• Refuse to discuss theology with Christians outside SCJ
• View all non-SCJ input as potentially “Satan’s lies”

This isolation makes it increasingly difficult to receive outside perspective that might help students recognize problems with SCJ’s teaching.

5. Preparation for Judgment of Others:

By comparing mainstream Christians to the Pharisees and to “worthless dregs” destined for judgment, the lesson prepares students to:

• View other Christians as spiritually inferior
• See themselves as part of an elite group
• Accept that most Christians will face judgment
• Believe that only SCJ members are being properly prepared

This mindset will later support SCJ’s teaching that they are the “144,000” while most Christians are deceived.

Biblical Response: The Gospel’s Humility

The contrast with the gospel’s message is stark:

The Gospel Produces Humility, Not Elitism:

• Luke 18:9-14: The parable of the Pharisee and the tax collector—the one who exalted himself was humbled, while the one who humbled himself was exalted
• Romans 12:3: “For by the grace given me I say to every one of you: Do not think of yourself more highly than you ought, but rather think of yourself with sober judgment”
• Philippians 2:3: “Do nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit. Rather, in humility value others above yourselves”

The gospel produces humility and unity, not elitism and division.

All Believers Are “Jars of Clay”:

• 2 Corinthians 4:7: “But we have this treasure in jars of clay to show that this all-surpassing power is from God and not from us”

We’re all ordinary vessels. Our value comes from Christ in us, not from our own excellence or knowledge.

God Opposes the Proud:

• James 4:6: “But he gives us more grace. That is why Scripture says: ‘God opposes the proud but shows favor to the humble.'”
• 1 Peter 5:5: “All of you, clothe yourselves with humility toward one another, because, ‘God opposes the proud but shows favor to the humble.'”

The attitude of “we’re noble vessels, they’re common vessels” is exactly the pride God opposes.

---

Part 4: Distinguishing Biblical Truth from SCJ Framework

What’s Biblical in This Lesson?

It’s important to acknowledge what’s actually true and biblical:

1. God is the Potter:

• Isaiah 64:8: “Yet you, Lord, are our Father. We are the clay, you are the potter”
• Jeremiah 18:6: “Like clay in the hand of the potter, so are you in my hand”

This is biblical truth.

2. God shapes us through His Word:

• John 15:3: “You are already clean because of the word I have spoken to you”
• Ephesians 5:26: “…to make her holy, cleansing her by the washing with water through the word”

This is orthodox teaching.

3. Trials refine us:

• 1 Peter 1:6-7: “…now for a little while you may have had to suffer grief in all kinds of trials. These have come so that the proven genuineness of your faith—of greater worth than gold, which perishes even though refined by fire—may result in praise, glory and honor”
• James 1:2-4: “Consider it pure joy, my brothers and sisters, whenever you face trials of many kinds, because you know that the testing of your faith produces perseverance”

This is biblical truth.

4. We should be filled with God’s Word:

• Colossians 3:16: “Let the message of Christ dwell among you richly”
• Psalm 119:11: “I have hidden your word in my heart that I might not sin against you”

This is sound biblical teaching.

5. Inner character matters more than outward appearance:

• 1 Samuel 16:7: “The Lord does not look at the things people look at. People look at the outward appearance, but the Lord looks at the heart”
• Matthew 23:25-26: Jesus’ condemnation of the Pharisees for being clean outside but dirty inside

This is biblical truth.

What’s Uniquely SCJ?

The problematic elements are subtle but significant:

1. The division of believers into “noble” and “common” categories:

• Biblical: All believers are being shaped by God (Philippians 1:6, Romans 8:29)
• SCJ: Some believers (SCJ members) are “noble vessels” while others are “common vessels” or “worthless dregs”

2. The suggestion that most Christians are like the Pharisees:

• Biblical: The Pharisees were condemned for hypocrisy, adding human traditions, and rejecting Christ
• SCJ: Christians with different interpretations are like the Pharisees—”worthless dregs” destined for judgment

3. The “spiritual fasting” concept as information control:

• Biblical: Fasting is abstaining from food for prayer and seeking God (Isaiah 58, Matthew 6:16-18)
• SCJ: “Spiritual fasting” means avoiding all Christian teaching outside SCJ (“Satan’s food”)

4. The emphasis on being “filled” creating dependency:

• Biblical: We are filled with the Holy Spirit (Ephesians 5:18) and should know God’s Word
• SCJ: Creates anxiety about being “filled enough” that’s resolved by staying in SCJ

5. The elitism and spiritual superiority:

• Biblical: All believers are “jars of clay” with the treasure of Christ (2 Corinthians 4:7)
• SCJ: SCJ members are “noble vessels” while others are inferior

6. The misuse of Revelation 15:7:

• Biblical: The seven bowls of wrath are God’s judgment on those persecuting the church
• SCJ: Uses this as a springboard to teach about believers as “bowls” being filled

The Blurred Lines

The genius of this lesson is how it blurs biblical truth with SCJ framework:

Example 1: God as Potter

• Biblical truth: God shapes all believers
• Biblical context: We’re all “jars of clay” with value from Christ in us (2 Corinthians 4:7)
• SCJ addition: Divides believers into “noble” (SCJ) and “common” (others) based on interpretation
• Result: Students accept elitism while thinking they’re believing biblical truth

Example 2: Being Filled with God’s Word

• Biblical truth: We should know and meditate on Scripture
• Biblical context: The Holy Spirit teaches us (1 John 2:27); we test everything (1 Thessalonians 5:21)
• SCJ addition: Only SCJ’s “opened” interpretation properly “fills” believers
• Result: Students become dependent on SCJ’s teaching rather than learning to study Scripture themselves

Example 3: Inner Character Matters

• Biblical truth: God looks at the heart, not outward appearance
• Biblical context: God sees our hearts and loves us despite our sin (Romans 5:8)
• SCJ addition: Suggests most Christians have dirty “insides” like the Pharisees
• Result: Students view other Christians as spiritually inferior

---

Part 5: The Larger Pattern

How This Lesson Fits SCJ’s Overall Strategy

This lesson is part of a carefully designed progression:

Lessons 1-15: Foundation

• Bible is “sealed” and requires special interpretation
• Most Christians don’t understand Scripture correctly
• Students need SCJ’s teaching to understand God’s Word

Lessons 16-20: Identity Formation

• Lesson 16-17 (Yeast): You’re influenced by what you’re exposed to
• Lesson 18-19 (Spiritual Food/Drink): You become what you consume spiritually
• Lesson 20 (Bowl): Your identity is as a vessel—are you noble or common?

Each lesson adds another layer to students’ spiritual identity, increasingly tied to SCJ.

Later Lessons: Solidifying the Framework

• Lesson 21 (Scales): You will be weighed and judged
• Lesson 22-23 (Rod/Fire): God’s Word judges; there are true and false teachers
• Intermediate Level: Christianity has been “destroyed”; SCJ is the restoration
• Advanced Level: Lee Man-hee is the promised pastor; SCJ is the 144,000

Lesson 20’s Specific Role:

This lesson creates spiritual identity and elitism that makes leaving psychologically difficult:

• “I’m a noble vessel being properly shaped”
• “Other Christians are common vessels or worthless dregs”
• “Leaving SCJ means becoming a common vessel again”
• “I need to ‘fast’ from other Christian teaching (Satan’s food)”

This identity investment and fear of “Satan’s food” keep students in SCJ even when they have doubts.

The Testimony Pattern

Chapter 14 of “Testing Shincheonji’s Claims” shares testimonies from former members. A common theme regarding the “vessel” teaching:

“I was taught that I was a ‘noble vessel’ being shaped by God through SCJ’s teaching, while other Christians were ‘common vessels’ or even ‘worthless dregs’ like the Pharisees. This made me feel spiritually superior and made it hard to leave—I thought leaving would mean becoming a ‘common vessel’ again. I also avoided reading any Christian materials outside SCJ because I was taught that was ‘Satan’s food’ I needed to ‘fast’ from. It took me months after leaving to realize that all believers are ‘jars of clay’ with value from Christ, not from having special knowledge.”

This lesson creates that elitism and isolation. The “noble vessel” identity becomes a psychological trap that makes leaving feel like spiritual regression.

---

Part 6: Practical Application and Warning Signs

For Current Students: Questions to Ask

If you’re currently taking this course, here are critical questions to consider:

1. About the “noble vs. common” framework:

• Does the New Testament actually divide believers into “noble” and “common” categories based on knowledge?
• What does 2 Corinthians 4:7 mean when it says we’re all “jars of clay”?
• Is the attitude “I’m noble, they’re common” consistent with Jesus’ teaching on humility?

2. About “spiritual fasting”:

• Does Isaiah 58 actually teach avoiding other Christian materials?
• Why does the Bible commend the Bereans for examining Paul’s teaching (Acts 17:11)?
• If truth can withstand scrutiny, why am I discouraged from reading other Christian perspectives?

3. About the Pharisees comparison:

• Were the Pharisees condemned for wrong interpretation or for hypocrisy and rejecting Christ?
• Is it appropriate to compare sincere Christians to the Pharisees just because they interpret some passages differently?
• What does this comparison reveal about SCJ’s attitude toward other Christians?

4. About being “filled”:

• Is my value based on how much I’m “filled” with interpretation, or on Christ in me?
• Am I growing in love, joy, peace (fruit of the Spirit), or just in interpretive knowledge?
• Is this teaching producing humility or elitism in me?

5. About where this is leading:

• If I’m being taught that most Christians are “common vessels” or “worthless dregs,” what am I being prepared to believe about the church?
• Why is my spiritual identity increasingly tied to one organization?
• What will I be taught in later levels about who the “noble vessels” are?

For Family and Friends: Warning Signs

If someone you love is taking this course, watch for these signs:

1. Spiritual elitism:

• Talks about being a “noble vessel” while others are “common”
• Shows subtle superiority about their biblical understanding
• Hints that most Christians don’t really understand Scripture

2. Isolation from other Christian input:

• Stops reading Christian books or listening to sermons
• Refers to other Christian teaching as “Satan’s food”
• Practices “spiritual fasting” from non-SCJ materials

3. Identity tied to the organization:

• Increasing focus on being “filled” with “the Word” (SCJ’s interpretation)
• Anxiety about being “filled enough” or being a “worthy vessel”
• Sees their spiritual value as dependent on staying in the study

4. Negative view of other Christians:

• Compares mainstream Christians to the Pharisees
• Suggests other Christians are “worthless dregs” or destined for judgment
• Shows decreasing respect for their pastor or church

5. Changed language:

• Uses phrases like “noble vessel,” “common vessel,” “spiritual fasting”
• Talks about being “shaped by the Potter” in ways that imply only SCJ shapes correctly
• Refers to being “filled” or “overflowing” with “the Word”

For Pastors and Counselors

Chapter 15 of “Testing Shincheonji’s Claims” shares insights from pastors who have helped people leave SCJ. Key recommendations regarding the “vessel” teaching:

1. Address the elitism: Help the person see that:

• All believers are “jars of clay” (2 Corinthians 4:7)
• Our value comes from Christ in us, not from our knowledge
• The gospel produces humility, not spiritual superiority

2. Clarify the Potter metaphor: Explain that:

• God is the Potter of all believers, not just one organization
• The Potter shapes us through trials and His Word, not through one group’s interpretation
• Romans 9:21-24 is about God’s sovereign election, not about achieving “noble” status through knowledge

3. Address the Pharisees comparison: Point out that:

• The Pharisees were condemned for hypocrisy and rejecting Christ, not for interpretive differences
• Comparing sincere Christians to the Pharisees is inappropriate and reveals SCJ’s elitism
• Jesus welcomed imperfect followers; He didn’t require perfect understanding

4. Redefine “spiritual fasting”: Show that:

• Biblical fasting is abstaining from food for prayer and seeking God
• Isaiah 58 is about social justice, not avoiding other Christian teaching
• The Bible encourages testing and examination (Acts 17:11, 1 Thessalonians 5:21)

5. Emphasize grace-based identity: Help the person rediscover that:

• Their value is in Christ, not in their knowledge or organization
• God loves them unconditionally, not based on how “filled” they are
• All believers are being shaped by God (Philippians 1:6)

6. Be patient: Understand that the “noble vessel” identity creates deep investment. Questioning SCJ feels like losing their spiritual identity. Deconstruction takes time.

7. Provide resources: Direct people to closerlookinitiative.com/shincheonji-examination for detailed refutation of SCJ’s elitism and clarification of biblical teaching on believers as vessels.

---

Part 7: The Biblical Alternative

The True Gospel of Believers as Vessels

The biblical teaching about believers as vessels is far more beautiful and humble than SCJ’s elitist system:

1. We are all “jars of clay”:

2 Corinthians 4:7: “But we have this treasure in jars of clay to show that this all-surpassing power is from God and not from us.”

Paul doesn’t divide believers into “noble jars” and “common jars.” He says we’re all ordinary clay pots. Our value comes from the treasure (Christ) within us, not from our own excellence.

2. Our value is in Christ, not in our “contents”:

• Colossians 2:9-10: “For in Christ all the fullness of the Deity lives in bodily form, and in Christ you have been brought to fullness. He is the head over every power and authority.”
• Ephesians 1:3: “Praise be to the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us in the heavenly realms with every spiritual blessing in Christ.”

We have fullness in Christ. Our value isn’t based on how much interpretive knowledge we’ve acquired.

3. God shapes all believers:

• Philippians 1:6: “…being confident of this, that he who began a good work in you will carry it on to completion until the day of Christ Jesus.”
• Romans 8:29: “For those God foreknew he also predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son”

God is at work shaping all believers, not just those in one organization.

4. The gospel produces humility, not elitism:

• Philippians 2:3-4: “Do nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit. Rather, in humility value others above yourselves, not looking to your own interests but each of you to the interests of the others.”
• Romans 12:3: “For by the grace given me I say to every one of you: Do not think of yourself more highly than you ought”

The gospel produces humility and unity, not the attitude “I’m noble, they’re common.”

5. We are all one body in Christ:

• 1 Corinthians 12:12-13: “Just as a body, though one, has many parts, but all its many parts form one body, so it is with Christ. For we were all baptized by one Spirit so as to form one body—whether Jews or Gentiles, slave or free—and we were all given the one Spirit to drink.”
• Ephesians 4:4-6: “There is one body and one Spirit, just as you were called to one hope when you were called; one Lord, one faith, one baptism; one God and Father of all, who is over all and through all and in all.”

All believers are part of one body. There’s no biblical category of “noble vessels” (one organization) vs. “common vessels” (everyone else).

How to Actually Study Potter/Vessel Passages

Instead of SCJ’s approach (fragmenting passages to create elitism), here’s how to study these passages in context:

1. Recognize the Potter metaphor is about God’s sovereignty and grace:

Isaiah 64:8: “Yet you, Lord, are our Father. We are the clay, you are the potter; we are all the work of your hand.”

Context: Israel is confessing their sin and appealing to God’s mercy. The Potter metaphor emphasizes God’s sovereignty and their dependence on His grace.

Jeremiah 18:1-6: The potter reshapes marred clay into something useful.

Context: God is showing that He can reshape Israel despite their rebellion. The emphasis is on God’s grace and patience, not on dividing people into categories.

Romans 9:19-24: “Does not the potter have the right to make out of the same lump of clay some pottery for special purposes and some for common use?”

Context: Paul is addressing why some Jews rejected Christ while Gentiles believed. He’s explaining God’s sovereign right to show mercy to whom He chooses. This is about God’s election and grace, not about believers achieving “noble” status through knowledge.

2. Let the New Testament interpret the metaphor:

2 Corinthians 4:7: “But we have this treasure in jars of clay to show that this all-surpassing power is from God and not from us.”

This is the New Testament’s clearest teaching on believers as vessels:

• We’re all “jars of clay” (ordinary, fragile)
• The treasure is Christ/the gospel
• The purpose is to show God’s power, not our excellence

3. Focus on the unified message:

The Bible’s unified message about believers as vessels:

• God is the Potter who shapes His people
• We are all ordinary vessels (“jars of clay”)
• Our value comes from Christ in us, not from our own excellence
• God shapes us through His Word and through trials
• All believers are being conformed to Christ’s image
• The gospel produces humility, not elitism

---

Conclusion: The Path Forward

For Those Currently in SCJ’s Course

If you’re reading this while taking SCJ’s Bible study, you’re at a critical juncture. The “vessel” teaching has likely created a sense of spiritual identity and purpose: I’m a noble vessel being shaped by the true Potter. I’m being filled with truth while others have worthless contents.

But consider this: The gospel produces humility, not elitism.

• 2 Corinthians 4:7: “But we have this treasure in jars of clay to show that this all-surpassing power is from God and not from us.”
• Philippians 2:3: “Do nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit. Rather, in humility value others above yourselves”
• James 4:6: “God opposes the proud but shows favor to the humble”

If teaching creates the attitude “I’m a noble vessel, they’re common vessels,” that teaching contradicts the gospel’s message of humility.

Chapter 27 of “Testing Shincheonji’s Claims” (“Your Investigation Begins”) provides practical steps:

1. Examine the passages in context: Read Romans 9, 2 Corinthians 4, and 2 Timothy 2 in their full context. Do they actually divide believers into “noble” and “common” categories?
2. Test the “spiritual fasting” concept: Read Isaiah 58 and John 8 in context. Are they actually about avoiding other Christian teaching?
3. Evaluate the fruit: Is this teaching producing humility and love, or elitism and judgment toward other Christians?
4. Seek outside perspectives: Talk to your pastor or mature Christian friends about what you’re learning. If the teaching is true, it will withstand scrutiny.
5. Visit closerlookinitiative.com/shincheonji-examination: This comprehensive resource provides detailed biblical refutation of SCJ’s elitism and vessel teaching.

For Those Who Have Left

Chapter 28 of “Testing Shincheonji’s Claims” (“Hope and Help”) offers guidance for former members. Key points regarding the “vessel” teaching:

1. You were never a “common vessel”: All believers are “jars of clay” with the treasure of Christ. Your value was never based on SCJ’s interpretation—it was always based on Christ in you.

2. The elitism was false: Other Christians aren’t “worthless dregs” or “common vessels.” They’re your brothers and sisters in Christ, equally valued by God.

3. You can engage with Christian teaching again: “Spiritual fasting” from other Christian materials was isolation, not biblical fasting. You can read, listen, and learn from the broader Christian tradition.

4. Your identity is in Christ: You don’t need to be a “noble vessel” in an elite organization. You’re a child of God, loved unconditionally, being shaped by the true Potter.

For the Christian Community

The existence of teachings like SCJ’s “vessel” doctrine should motivate us to:

1. Emphasize grace-based identity: Our value is in Christ, not in our knowledge or achievements. We must clearly teach that all believers are equally valued by God.

2. Model humility: The gospel produces humility, not spiritual superiority. We must model the attitude “I’m a jar of clay with the treasure of Christ,” not “I’m a noble vessel and others are common.”

3. Encourage discernment without isolation: We should test all teaching (1 Thessalonians 5:21) while engaging with the broader Christian tradition, not isolating ourselves from other perspectives.

4. Celebrate unity in diversity: The body of Christ includes believers with various interpretations on secondary issues. We must emphasize our unity in Christ rather than creating divisions based on interpretive knowledge.

5. Respond with compassion: Those caught in or leaving SCJ need grace, not condemnation. They were seeking to be faithful “vessels” for God; they were simply misled about what that means.

Final Thoughts

This lesson—Lesson 20 on figurative bowls—appears to be encouraging biblical teaching about God shaping us as vessels for His purposes. But beneath the surface, it’s constructing an elitist system that divides believers into “noble” (SCJ members) and “common” (everyone else) categories, creating spiritual superiority and isolation.

The principles in “Testing Shincheonji’s Claims: Two Lenses, One Story” help us see through the deception:

• Chapter 21-23: God’s character is grace and love, not performance-based acceptance
• Chapter 11-13: Recognize isolation tactics (“spiritual fasting”) and demand verifiable evidence
• Chapter 18-20: Test authority claims and watch for creative fulfillment
• Chapter 24-26: Keep the Bible’s unified message centered on Christ
• Chapter 27-28: Know that investigation is possible and healing is available

The true gospel is better than SCJ’s counterfeit:

• All believers are “jars of clay”, not divided into noble and common
• Our value is in Christ, not in our interpretive knowledge
• God shapes all believers, not just one organization
• The gospel produces humility, not elitism
• We are one body in Christ, not divided into superior and inferior vessels

May those reading this find freedom in Christ, who makes all believers into vessels of honor—not through special knowledge, but through simple faith in Him.

---

Additional Resources

For more detailed refutation of Shincheonji’s specific doctrines and claims:

Visit: closerlookinitiative.com/shincheonji-examination

This comprehensive resource provides:

• Detailed analysis of SCJ’s elitism and “noble vessel” teaching
• Biblical clarification of the Potter/vessel metaphor
• Examination of 2 Corinthians 4:7 and Romans 9 in context
• Refutation of the “spiritual fasting” concept as information control
• Testimonies from former members about the elitism created by this teaching
• Guidance for families and counselors
• Resources for rediscovering grace-based identity

The examination is thorough, biblically grounded, and presented with grace—exactly what’s needed to counter SCJ’s elitist but sophisticated system.

---

“But we have this treasure in jars of clay to show that this all-surpassing power is from God and not from us.” — 2 Corinthians 4:7

“Do nothing out of selfish ambition or vain conceit. Rather, in humility value others above yourselves.” — Philippians 2:3

“For by the grace given me I say to every one of you: Do not think of yourself more highly than you ought, but rather think of yourself with sober judgment, in accordance with the faith God has distributed to each of you.” — Romans 12:3

“God opposes the proud but shows favor to the humble.” — James 4:6