Lee Man Hee

by ichthus

Lee Man Hee (born September 15, 1931) is the founder and leader of the Shincheonji Church of Jesus, the Temple of the Tabernacle of the Testimony, a controversial new religious movement founded in 1984 in South Korea. As of 2025, he is 94 years old.

In Shincheonji doctrine, Lee is revered as the “Promised Pastor”—the one foretold in Scripture to appear at the time of Revelation’s fulfillment. He claims to be the “New John”, the only person on earth who has seen and heard all the events of Revelation physically fulfilled. Followers believe that God and Jesus have entrusted him alone with the opened scroll of Revelation (Rev 10), making him the only authorized interpreter of biblical prophecy in this era.

Lee has written several doctrinal books used in SCJ’s global Bible study curriculum, including The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation and The Creation of Heaven and Earth. These texts position him as the spiritual figure who fulfills roles such as the one who overcomes, the male child of Revelation 12, the faithful and wise servant of Matthew 24, and even the white horse Jesus rides in Revelation 19 (symbolically).

While Lee denies being Jesus reincarnated, he is considered by followers as the spokesperson of Jesus at the Second Coming, and salvation is taught to come only through his testimony.

See Terms:

WHO IS LEE MAN HEE IN SHINCHEONJI?

Lee Man Hee (born September 15, 1931), known as Chairman Lee, is the founder and leader of Shincheonji Church of Jesus, the Temple of the Tabernacle of the Testimony, established on March 14, 1984, in Gwacheon, South Korea. In SCJ theology, Lee is considered the Promised Pastor, the “one who overcomes” in Revelation, and the final messenger chosen by Jesus to testify to the fulfillment of the entire book of Revelation.

His Korean name, Man Hee (만희), means “full of light”.

In Shincheonji doctrine, Lee Man-hee is not considered Jesus Christ himself, but he is regarded as the “Promised Pastor” and the “One Who Overcomes” (Revelation 2–3; Revelation 21:6–7), appointed directly by Jesus to fulfill the entire book of Revelation at the time of the Second Coming. According to SCJ theology, this divine appointment took place in 1977 in South Korea, when Lee received the command to testify to everything he had seen and heard, just as the apostle John was commanded in Revelation 22:8 and 16.

The Tabernacle Temple (장막성전) was considered the first heaven and first earth (Revelation 6:12–14), and within it, seven messengers (stars) were chosen as lamps to guide the people to the true light. These messengers were part of God’s initial work in this era, but they later fell into corruption through the teachings of the Nicolaitans and the infiltration of the Dragon, which Shincheonji identifies with the Stewardship Education Center (SEC).

Lee Man-hee, a faithful member at the time, witnessed the betrayal and destruction firsthand. Following Revelation 2–3, he was instructed to write letters to the seven messengers, testifying about their corruption and urging repentance. When they rejected his testimony, it fulfilled the pattern of betrayal, destruction, and salvation found throughout the Bible.

By remaining obedient and not compromising with the false teachings, Lee Man-hee overcame the Dragon and the forces of deception. As a result, he was granted all the promises to the one who overcomes—including access to the tree of life, the white stone, the iron scepter, and becoming God’s son and Jesus’ representative. He was entrusted with the open scroll (Revelation 10) and sent to testify to all nations about the physical fulfillment of Revelation.

Just as Jesus said in John 13:20, “Whoever receives the one I send receives me, and whoever receives me receives the one who sent me,” Shincheonji teaches that accepting Lee Man-hee is equivalent to accepting Jesus, because he is the one whom Jesus has sent.
Therefore, rejecting Lee Man-hee is equated with rejecting Jesus and God.

Though Lee Man-hee is not considered divine, he is regarded as the flesh vessel through whom Jesus and God dwell, making him the mouthpiece of Jesus. He is also referred to as the bride of the Lamb, the one prepared to receive Jesus at the time of the wedding banquet (Revelation 19:7–9), when spirit and flesh unite during the First Resurrection.

As the only person who has seen and heard the entire fulfillment of Revelation, Shincheonji teaches that salvation in this era can only come through his testimony—making him the savior-like figure of our time, just as Noah, Moses, and Jesus were in theirs.


Promised Pastors in Shincheonji Theology

Time Period Promised Pastor Role in God’s Work
Era of Judgment (Flood) Noah Saved a generation through the ark
Exodus Moses Led God’s people out of Egypt
First Coming Jesus Fulfilled OT prophecy and brought salvation
Second Coming Lee Man-hee Fulfills Revelation and testifies to it

Lee Man-hee is said to stand in the same line of promise as these figures—not as the Christ, but as the appointed instrument through whom Jesus’ mission continues today.

According to SCJ doctrine, Lee Man Hee fulfills multiple roles prophesied in the New Testament, especially in the book of Revelation. He is described in SCJ writings as:

  1. The Promised Pastor –  Appointed by God and Jesus to testify the fulfillment of Revelation.
  2. The One Who Overcomes – Revelation 2–3: the victor who receives all promises.
  3. The Faithful and Wise Servant –  Matthew 24:45 – the one who gives food (word) at the proper time.
  4. The Male Child – Revelation 12:5 – born from the woman, destined to rule all nations.
  5. The Seventh Trumpet – Revelation 11:15 – one who declares the final trumpet of salvation.
  6. The White Horse Jesus Rides – Revelation 19:11 – symbolic of the person Jesus uses at his return.
  7. The Iron Scepter –  Revelation 2:27, 12:5 – authority to rule the nations.
  8. The Pillar in God’s Temple – Revelation 3:12 – eternal member of God’s house.
  9. The Golden Censer – mediating prayers of saints (Revelation 8:3–5).
  10. The One Who Eats the Open Scroll – the open word of Revelation (Revelation 10)
  11. One of the Two Witnesses – Revelation 11:3 – paired with Hong Jong-hyo in SCJ theology.
  12. The Bride of Christ – (Revelation 19 & 21) – The union of spirit and flesh, where Lee Man Hee, as the chosen “flesh,” unites with the spirit of Jesus, forming the perfected vessel through which God’s will is fulfilled on earth.
  13. The Messenger of Jesus –  Revelation 1:1 – sent to testify the word of God and what he has seen.
  14. The Tree of Life – Revelation 22:1–2 – gives eternal life through the revealed word.
  15. The General President (Comforter in the flesh) – continuation of Jesus’ work.
  16. The Advocate / Counselor – John 14:26 – teaches all things and reminds the world of Jesus’ words.
  17. The Rider with a Sharp Sword – Revelation 19:15 – judges with the word of God.
  18. The Throne of Jesus – Revelation 3:21 – one who sits on Jesus’ throne spiritually.
  19. New John (새 요한) –  Revelation 10, 22:16 – the only person who saw and heard all Revelation events fulfilled.
  20. The Oil Seller – Matthew 25:9 – Lee is said to represent the seller of “spiritual oil” (i.e. revealed word) that the foolish virgins must seek to be saved during the end times.
  21. The One Sealing the 144,000 – LMH seals the spiritual Israel (Rev 7).
  22. The Morning Star – Rev 2:28 -With the overcomer, symbolizing Jesus’ spirit with him.
  23. Son of God – Rev 21:7 – Inheritor of God’s kingdom as overcomer.
  24. The Open Scroll Eater -Rev 10 – Receives revealed Word and proclaims it.
  25. The Man with the Measuring Rod – Measures temple and worshippers (Rev 11:1)
  26. The Rider with Bow – Rev 6:2Conquers spiritually; SCJ views this as LMH’s mission.
  27. The New Name – Rev 3:12 – Jesus’ new name written on LMH.

These titles emphasize Lee’s unique authority to interpret the Bible, his exclusive role in the end times, and his spiritual identity as the one who inherits everything Jesus promised to those who overcome.

SCJ members believe that salvation is only possible through Lee Man Hee, since he alone knows the secrets of Revelation and testifies to its actual reality.


COMPARISONS TO BIBLICAL FIGURES

SCJ compares Lee Man Hee to several figures:

  • Jesus – Lee is not Jesus in the flesh, but represents Jesus’ second coming in spirit, fulfilling his mission (not bodily reincarnation).

  • John the Apostle – Like John who received Revelation, Lee is believed to have seen and heard its fulfillment and now testifies it.

  • Moses – As Moses led the Israelites physically, Lee leads New Spiritual Israel spiritually.

  • Paul – As Paul spread the gospel, Lee spreads the testimony of Revelation.

SCJ insists that Lee is not divine, but he is the one chosen by Jesus to reveal all truth in this age.


 AFFILIATED TITLES, NAMES, AND STRUCTURE

  • Shincheonji Church of Jesus, the Temple of the Tabernacle of the Testimony

  • New Heaven and New Earth (NHNE) – reference to Revelation 21:1

  • New John – because he testifies like John (Revelation 1:2)

  • Chairman Lee – official SCJ title

  • SSN (성신의 이름) – “Name of the Holy Spirit” or “Representative of the Holy Spirit”

According to SCJ structure:

God → Jesus → Angel → Lee Man Hee (Comforter in the flesh) → 12 Tribe Leaders → 144,000 + Great MultitudeAll combined


Year Age Event
1931 0 Born in Cheongdo, South Korea.
1967 36 Joined Tabernacle Temple under Yoo Jae-Yeol
1971 40 Left Tabernacle Temple, alleging corruption
1977 46 Ordained by a spiritual man (claimed to be Jesus) in a vision
1980 49 Received open scroll (Revelation 10) and began testimony
1984 52 Founded Shincheonji Church of JesusAll combined
2020 89 Arrested and detained during COVID-19 outbreak; later released

CLAIMS TO IMMORTALITY

SCJ does not explicitly state that Lee Man Hee is immortal, but his age (now 94 as of 2025) and role as the eternal witness suggest that followers believe he may not die until the full completion of God’s kingdom on earth.

Statements such as:

“No one can come to Jesus, gain eternal life, or enter heaven except through the one who overcomes”
imply a salvific exclusivity tied to his ongoing life and ministry.


Title Year Published Lee’s Age Summary / Purpose
1. The Reality of Revelation (현실계시록) 1985 54 Lee’s first book detailing his early visions and the foundational doctrine of the physical fulfillment of Revelation. Introduces his role as the one who overcomes and testifies to the end times. Often considered the earliest theological manual for SCJ teachings.
2. The True Story of Revelation 2 1988 57 Follows up on the 1985 book, adding more prophetic fulfillment claims. It also narrates Lee’s departure from the Tabernacle Temple and emphasizes his new role as “New John.”
3. The Physical Fulfillment of Revelation (계시록 실상) ca. 2007 ~76 SCJ’s most central doctrinal textbook. Interprets all 22 chapters of Revelation as already fulfilled in Korea through SCJ history. Provides extensive spiritual mapping and allegory. Used in the advanced level of SCJ Bible study.
4. The Creation of Heaven and Earth (천지창조) 1st Ed: 2007
2nd Ed: 2014
76–83 A beginner-to-intermediate level text used in SCJ’s Zion Mission Center. Covers foundational theology, including the spiritual meaning of creation, Adam, sin, covenants, and restoration. Often used to transition new members into Revelation study.
5. Mankind’s Greatest Concern (Religious World’s Interest) 1984 53 Apocalyptic warning text. Urges the world to listen to the “sound of the trumpet” and proclaims imminent judgment. Considered part of SCJ’s early evangelistic material.
6. Shintan (신탄) (Discontinued) ~1995 ~64 Allegedly written by Lee but later denounced as altered by defectors. Originally taught allegorical interpretations of biblical prophecies but later withdrawn and hidden from members. Now considered apocryphal by SCJ.

 Where to Access These Books

  • Official Shincheonji site: https://en.shincheonji.kr

  • Book PDFs (some user-translated versions):

    • The Reality of Revelation, Creation of Heaven and Earth, and Physical Fulfillment of Revelation available via internal SCJ resources or leaked archives.

  • Reference Archive: MHL Reddit Book Archive – includes official and unreleased books in Korean and English.


Lee Man-hee Quotes in his Books

From SCJ official texts:

  • Reality of Revelation, Chapter 22:

    “The one who saw and heard all the events of Revelation is the promised pastor… only he can testify.”

  • Creation of Heaven and Earth, p. 342:

    “Without hearing the testimony of the one who overcomes, no one can be saved.”

  • Physical Fulfillment of Revelation, p. 197:

    “To reject the one who testifies is to reject the one who sent him.”


  1. Date manipulation – SCJ shifted its founding date from 1980 to 1984 for symbolic reasons.

  2. Cult accusations – Many former members and watchdog groups classify SCJ as a destructive high-control group.

  3. Allegiance to man – Critics argue that placing salvation on a man contradicts biblical teaching (Isaiah 43:11; John 14:6; Acts 4:12).

  4. Failed prophecy concerns – Affiliations with date-setting groups like Baek Man-bong’s Recreation Church, who predicted the end in 1980.

  5. COVID-19 arrest – Lee was detained for allegedly withholding data during a pandemic outbreak tied to SCJ’s Daegu branch.


Additional References for more Exploration

(As understood and promoted by Shincheonji Church of Jesus)

Birth and Early Life
Lee Man Hee was born on September 15, 1931, in Cheongdo, North Gyeongsang Province, South Korea, into a poor farming family. His grandfather, a man of faith, named him “Man-Hee,” meaning “complete light,” after dreaming of a bright light shining upon his daughter-in-law. From a young age, Lee practiced prayer devoutly, developing a habit of praying on mountain tops every Sunday morning and evening, though he initially did not attend a formal church.

Military and Spiritual Awakening
During the Korean War, Lee served as a combat soldier. It was during these war-torn years, facing death and hunger, that he began seeking God more earnestly, often praying under the stars. One night, a large star appeared to him, and soon after, he experienced what he describes as a spiritual encounter—he saw a “person from heaven.” He made a blood covenant with God and pledged his life to serve Him. This moment marked a turning point that led to intense spiritual discipline and trials.

Calling and Ministry Formation
Lee claims he was later directed by a heavenly voice to go to the Tabernacle Temple in Gwacheon. Although he served there, he became disillusioned with what he saw as corruption in the church. He attempted to reform it, but opposition forced him to leave. He returned to his hometown, where he devoted himself for seven years to a rural renewal movement. It was during this time that he received the command to send letters of repentance to the leaders of the Tabernacle Temple, initiating his prophetic mission.

Vision of Revelation Fulfilled
Lee testifies that he is the one who has “seen and heard” all the events of Revelation fulfilled in the physical world (Revelation 22:8,16). According to SCJ, Revelation was fulfilled in South Korea starting from 1984, and Lee was the only person to witness its entire process. He claims to be the one who “received and ate the open scroll” from Revelation 10 and that Jesus sent him as His messenger to testify to all the churches.

“No one has testified to the reality of the Revelation for 2000 years, but Jesus chose me to testify.”
— Lee Man Hee, November 2024 Word SeminarTestimony on the Fulfil…

Founding of Shincheonji
As more people gathered to hear his testimony, Lee formally established the Shincheonji Church of Jesus, the Temple of the Tabernacle of the Testimony. He refers to this community as the “kingdom of God created on earth as it is in heaven,” fulfilling Revelation 21.

Global Evangelism and Peace Missions
Lee has traveled the world through the “Word Crusade” seminars. In 2014, he was invited to Mindanao, Philippines, where he mediated the first civilian peace agreement between Muslim and Christian groups through his NGO, HWPL (Heavenly Culture, World Peace, Restoration of Light). He has since remained active in interfaith dialogues and educational programs, claiming to fulfill Isaiah’s vision of peace.


Symbolic Titles and Roles Given to Lee Man Hee by Shincheonji

Shincheonji teachings associate Lee with numerous symbolic titles drawn from the Bible:

Title Source / Symbolic Reference
The Promised Pastor Revelation 1:1; 22:16; 10:11
New John Successor to Apostle John
The One Who Overcomes Revelation 2–3
The One Who Eats the Open Scroll Revelation 10
The Messenger Sent by Jesus Revelation 22:16
The Male Child Revelation 12:5
The Iron Scepter Bearer Revelation 2:26–27
The White Horse Rider (Jesus’ vessel) Revelation 6:2; 19:11–16
The Faithful and Wise Servant Matthew 24:45–47
The 7th Trumpet Revelation 11:15
The One Seated on the Throne Revelation 3:21 (as Jesus’ throne)
The Oil Seller Matthew 25:9 (wise virgins’ parable)
The Bride of Christ Revelation 21:9 (allegorized as New Heaven New Earth)
The Advocate John 14:16–17, interpreted in SCJ as one who defends truth
The First Resurrection Participant Revelation 20:4–6

Shincheonji asserts that Lee is not Jesus, but is the chosen spiritual representative of Jesus—his “advocate” or “promised pastor.” However, many critics claim this borders on deification, due to the exalted roles and near-messianic status Lee holds in SCJ theology.


Key Life Events (with Age References)

Year Event Lee’s Age
1931 Born in Cheongdo 0
1950–1953 Korean War service 19–22
1957 Begins receiving visions, commits in blood 26
~1965–72 Serves in Tabernacle Temple, then leaves 34–41
1978 Ordered to send letters of repentance 47
1984 Founding of Shincheonji 53
2013 Begins mission trips to the Philippines 82
2014 Mediates Mindanao Peace Treaty (HWPL) 83
2020 SCJ COVID controversy in Korea 89
2024–2025 Leads “Word Crusade” seminar world tour 93–94

The “Sensitive” Article and Its Details

In the mid-1970s, South Korean media published exposés on the Gwacheon Tabernacle Temple (장막성전) – the apocalyptic sect led by Yoo Jae-yeol (often called the “young servant”). One notable piece was a Dong-A Ilbo investigative report on April 3, 1975 (「신흥종교 단체 ‘장막성전교회’ 수사」). This article revealed highly sensitive, damaging information about the group’s inner workings[s]. According to these reports (citing prosecutors and former members), the Tabernacle Temple’s leadership was involved in fraud, extortion, and abuse: for example, believers’ properties were confiscated or mortgaged under false pretenses, followers’ homes, farms, and even factories were effectively seized, and female members were sexually exploited by the leaders[s]. Yoo Jae-yeol had also enriched himself with a “luxury house” built from devotees’ donations[s]. These revelations suggested that the cult was not a holy “refuge” at all, but a hotbed of corruption. Such explosive content could indeed “collapse” the church by shattering the faith of its members if it became widely known. (The Dong-A Ilbo report and similar pieces in Kyunghyang Shinmun[s] were so serious that law enforcement intervened, leading to the cult’s downfall.)

Translation: According to a Dong-A Ilbo article from 1975, “the death rate was unusually high in the area around the Tabernacle Temple, and all the property of believers was extorted… Yoo gathered ~2,000 believers and used their donations and labor to build a church and a luxury house. While expanding the church, Yoo and the leaders seized members’ houses, farms, and rice fields by mortgaging them, and even sexually abused female members[s]. These findings were forwarded to prosecutors, resulting in Yoo’s arrest in 1975 on dozens of charges including fraud and violence[s]. Clearly, an article outlining such abuses would be devastating to the group’s credibility.

Lee Man-hee’s Reaction – Fear and Departure

Lee Man-hee (born 1931), who later founded Shincheonji, was originally a member of Yoo’s Tabernacle Temple. The story in question alleges that Lee read one of these damning articles (perhaps in a magazine or newspaper) that exposed the Tabernacle Temple’s darkest secrets – information “so sensitive it could collapse the church.” Upon learning the truth, Lee supposedly feared for his life and fled the movement.

Historical accounts support much of this narrative: In the early 1970s, Lee Man-hee himself became disillusioned with Yoo’s group. In fact, Lee and another member (Hong Jae-ho) went so far as to file a legal complaint against Yoo’s church in 1971[s] – indicating Lee knew about (and objected to) the internal wrongdoing even before the media exposés. By 1975–76, when Yoo Jae-yeol was tried and convicted of fraud (initially 5 years in prison, reduced on appeal)[s], the Tabernacle Temple’s corruption was public knowledge. Lee Man-hee later recounted that during this period he confronted the leadership: giving “voice to many members,” he wrote letters to the sect’s seven top leaders denouncing their corruption and urging them to repent[s]. In response, Lee says, the leaders turned on him – he was “threatened and beaten” repeatedly for whistleblowing[s]. Fearing further violence, he “gave up his attempts at reforming the Temple” and ultimately left the organization[s.. These accounts make it clear that Lee genuinely feared for his safety as a result of knowing “too much” about the group’s illicit affairs. In other words, once he had evidence of the leaders’ misdeeds (whether through personal observation, insider testimony, or reading a published article), his life was in danger. Shincheonji’s official timeline notes that by March 14, 1984 Lee Man-hee had “left the Tabernacle Temple” and founded his own church, Shincheonji Church of Jesus, taking with him a number of disillusioned former members[s].

Note: We did not find a direct reference in primary sources to “a magazine article that Lee read.” It is very plausible, however, that Lee became aware of Yoo’s scandal through Korean news magazines or newspapers of the time. Contemporary media like Dong-A Ilbo and Kyunghyang Shinmun were reporting the cult’s crimes[s]. Lee’s letters and subsequent flight suggest he had indeed learned of very sensitive information. Whether he literally read it in a magazine or heard it from investigators, the effect was the same – he realized the church was rotten to the core and that revealing this could bring it down.

Shincheonji’s Official Version vs. Recorded History

Shincheonji’s own materials and testimonies do recount this episode, though in a stylized, doctrinal manner. In Shincheonji’s theology, the fall of the Tabernacle Temple is interpreted as the fulfillment of certain Revelation prophecies. For example, Shincheonji teaches a pattern of “betrayal–destruction–salvation” in the end times. They identify Yoo Jae-yeol as the “betrayer” who broke the covenant, and a Presbyterian pastor (Mr. Oh Pyeong-ho) as the “destroyer” who invaded the Tabernacle Temple, leading to its collapse[s]. Lee Man-hee, in turn, is lauded as “the one who overcomes” or the victorious shepherd who stood firm and then established the new spiritual Israel (Shincheonji) after the old Tabernacle was judged[s]. This narrative is embedded in Chairman Lee’s sermons and books. For instance, Shincheonji claims that Lee is the “New John” of Revelation who “received and ate the open scroll” (Rev 10) – meaning God gave him a full revelation of the situation[s]. They say through an angel, Jesus showed Lee all the events of Revelation, including the betrayal of the seven messengers (the Tabernacle leaders)[s]. In plainer terms, Shincheonji doctrine spiritualizes the 1970s crisis: Lee’s act of reading that “open book” and writing letters parallels Apostle John receiving Revelation’s message to the seven churches. Shincheonji textbooks note that Lee wrote letters to the seven “messengers” of the Tabernacle Temple (fulfilling Rev 2–3) and that these leaders did not repent – thereby betraying the movement[s]. Lee is said to have “seen and heard all the events” of Revelation unfold in Korea, including the Tabernacle’s corruption, hence he testifies that prophecy was fulfilled in that very church[s]. Nowhere in Shincheonji’s official teaching, however, do they explicitly mention the name of a magazine or newspaper. The story is framed as divine revelation rather than a news scoop.

Nonetheless, Shincheonji’s published histories (including Lee’s autobiographical remarks) do match the broad facts: they acknowledge that the Tabernacle Temple was rife with corruption, that Lee denounced it and was persecuted, and that the church eventually collapsed. For example, Chairman Lee’s book The Creation of Heaven and Earth (신천지 창조) and other official sources describe how the “seven stars” of the Tabernacle fell from grace, how an agent of mainstream Christianity (“Stewardship Education Center”) entered and destroyed that church in 1980, and how Lee “overcame” and started anew in 1984[s][s]. Shincheonji often omits the gory secular details (financial fraud and sexual abuse) and instead emphasizes spiritual betrayal. But the kernel of the story – Lee’s life being in danger due to what he discovered – is affirmed in Shincheonji lore. In fact, Shincheonji members learn that Chairman Lee was beaten for exposing sin in the former church[s]. He is revered as the faithful witness who survived an attempt to silence him, much like “John” in Revelation surviving persecution. So while Shincheonji might not say “Lee read Monthly Chosun magazine and got scared,” they absolutely teach about a taboo knowledge that Lee gained, which caused the first Tabernacle to fall.

Independent & Korean Sources – Corroboration and Criticism

Outside sources – including secular news, Christian watchdogs, and academic researchers – largely corroborate the factual events but often dispute Shincheonji’s interpretation. Key points from independent accounts include:

  • Yoo Jae-yeol’s Cult and Collapse: By the late 1970s the Tabernacle Temple was unraveling. Yoo’s doomsday prophecy (Nov 1, 1969) had failed, and ex-members (including Lee) sued him for fraud[s]. In 1975–76 Yoo and several top aides were arrested and convicted on charges ranging from fraud and embezzlement to violence[s]. After serving a reduced sentence, Yoo abdicated leadership. To avoid further government crackdowns during President Chun’s 1980 “religious purification” campaign, evangelist Oh Pyung-ho (who held a Presbyterian pastor’s license) took over the Tabernacle Temple and merged it into a Presbyterian denomination[s][s]. Essentially, the sect dissolved itself in 1980: its assets were handed over or sold off (the Gwacheon compound was bought by the Seoul government and demolished to build Seoul Grand Park)[s]. Yoo Jae-yeol emigrated to the United States in October 1980, publicly “repenting” and later pursuing a career as a businessmanshinchonjiandthebible.blogspot.com. (He would eventually return to Korea decades later. Notably, Yoo denounces Lee Man-hee’s Shincheonji teachings to this day, partly because Lee branded Yoo a traitor for yielding the churchshinchonjiandthebible.blogspot.com.)
  • Lee Man-hee’s Role: Independent histories confirm that Lee was an early follower of Yoo. After leaving the Olive Tree revival in 1967, Lee joined Yoo’s Temple of the Tabernacle and even rose to a position of trust[s]shinchonjiandthebible.blogspot.com. However, Lee’s loyalty waned as Yoo’s corruption became evident. The first lawsuit in 1971 lists Lee Man-hee among the plaintiffs[s], suggesting he attempted to hold Yoo accountable through legal means. It’s documented that Lee (and others) accused Yoo of swindling devotees when the promised “end of the world” never happened[s]. By the late ’70s, Lee was associated with a splinter group led by Baek Man-bong (one of Yoo’s defected “angels”)[s]. Baek himself proclaimed an end-times date (March 13, 1980); when that failed, Lee and others left Baek as well[s]. Many of these fractured followers rallied around Lee, who presented himself as carrying the mantle of truth after all others had fallen. On March 14, 1984, Lee formally established Shincheonji (full name: “Shincheonji Church of Jesus, the Temple of the Tabernacle of the Testimony”)[s]. Early Shincheonji was essentially one of several “post-Tabernacle Temple” movements that emerged – and it has since become the largest and most infamous of those factionsshinchonjiandthebible.blogspot.com[s].
  • Mr. “Yoo Jr.” and Fears of an Insider: The question references “Mr. Yoo Jr.” – which indeed points to Yoo Jae-yeol, who was very young (18) when leading the sect and was often called the “young servant.” Contemporary Korean sources describe how paranoid the Yoo camp became about insiders leaking information. It’s implied that Yoo and his close associates viewed Lee Man-hee as a threat once he began to question them. Shincheonji’s own narrative supports this: as soon as Lee confronted the seven leaders, “he was repeatedly threatened and beaten” until he had to stop[s]. In other words, Yoo knew Lee had intimate knowledge of the sect’s wrongdoings (“knew too much”) and tried to silence him. Some Korean Christian commentators have noted that Shincheonji embellishes this turning point into a grand spiritual drama, when in reality it was a power struggle and an attempt to cover up crimes. For example, an analysis in Kookmin Ilbo in 2020 pointed out that Lee Man-hee portrays the Tabernacle Temple as a holy “first dwelling place” that betrayed its mission, but the real cause of its collapse was Yoo Jae-yeol’s arrest for fraud[s][s]. In other words, independent observers see Shincheonji’s version as a half-truth: yes, the church fell apart and Lee left under duress, but not simply because of “betrayal by Babylon” – it was because the leader got caught scamming his flock.
  • Evidence for the “Letters” and Article: One critical question has been whether Lee Man-hee truly wrote letters to the seven pastors (as he claims) and whether such documents or the exact magazine article can be found. No known archival copy of Lee’s 1979–1980 letters has surfaced publicly (they were likely private missives). Some ex-members have expressed skepticism about the literal existence of those letters, suggesting it could be Shincheonji lore to align with Revelation 2–3[s]. However, the broad event is supported by multiple sources: Massimo Introvigne’s research notes that Lee did rally supporters and urge the Tabernacle leaders to repent, which led to his expulsion amid violence[s]. As for the magazine/newspaper article, the Dong-A Ilbo piece (1975) and subsequent trial coverage (1976) are verifiable in Korean news archives. It’s highly likely these were the sources of the “shocking information” – for example, the Dong-A Ilbo report outlined exactly the kind of hidden crimes (mortgage scams, secret sexual liaisons) that ordinary members would have found scandalous and faith-shattering[s]. In sum, while Shincheonji doesn’t cite “Weekly Magazine X, 1970s” in its sermons, the content of that era’s media exposés absolutely aligns with what Lee came to know and fear.

Timeline of Key Events (1966–1984)

To put it all in perspective, here is a brief timeline of the Tabernacle Temple saga and Lee Man-hee’s departure:

  • 1966: Temple of the Tabernacle (장막성전) founded in Gwacheon by Yoo Jae-yeol (18) along with his father Yoo In-gu and a circle of “7 angels.” It splintered from the earlier Olive Tree movementshinchonjiandthebible.blogspot.com[s]. Yoo taught that he was the end-times “Counselor” and that their commune would be the only refuge at Armageddonshinchonjiandthebible.blogspot.com[s]. Lee Man-hee joins as an early member in 1967[s].
  • 1969: Yoo predicts the end of the world for September (later November) 1969, gathering ~2,000 followers expecting salvation in the Tabernacle[s][s]. Nothing happens. Disillusionment follows; some leaders (e.g. Angel Solomon Baek Man-bong) leave in 1969–70, and rifts form[s].
  • 1971: A group of disgruntled believers files a police report/lawsuit against Yoo’s church for deception. Among the complainants are Lee Man-hee and Hong Jae-ho (who would later co-found Shincheonji)[s]. This indicates Lee’s first break with Yoo’s leadership.
  • 1975: Korean authorities launch a full investigation of the Tabernacle Temple. Major newspapers (Dong-A Ilbo, etc.) publish exposés in early 1975 detailing the group’s abuses[s]. In September 1975, Yoo Jae-yeol and three aides are arrested by the Seoul District Prosecutor’s Office on a raft of charges: fraud, embezzlement, violence, even falsifying IDs to swindle members[s].
  • 1976: Yoo is convicted in the first trial and sentenced to 5 years in prison[s]. (On appeal, this was reduced to 2.5 years with 4 years’ probation[s].) The scandal causes mass defections – the Tabernacle Temple rapidly loses members and moral authority. It’s around this time (mid-1970s) that Lee Man-hee begins speaking of a “fulfillment of Revelation” taking place – implying that Yoo’s church equates to the fallen stars and that a new work of God is coming. Lee is loosely associated with Mr. Baek’s breakaway sect in the late ’70s[s].
  • 1977–1979: (Shincheonji lore: This period is when Lee Man-hee is said to have received the “open scroll” from heaven – symbolically meaning he fully understood the situation.) In 1979, Lee, with support from other remaining loyalists, writes letters to the seven pastors (the “messengers” of the Tabernacle) urging repentance[s]. These letters correspond to the biblical messages in Revelation chapters 2–3. The appeal is rejected; instead, Lee faces violent retribution. Over 1979–1981, Lee is beaten and threatened by former colleagues who view him as a traitor or agitator[s]. Fearing for his life, he cuts ties completely. (One account says Lee even retreated to a mountain to pray during this exile, much like John of Patmos – though this may be hagiographical.)
  • 1980: The Tabernacle Temple officially collapses. Amid an anti-cult crackdown by the government, Pastor Oh Pyung-ho takes control (with Yoo in jail/on probation) and aligns the group with the Presbyterian Church to avoid persecution[s][s]. Essentially, Yoo Jae-yeol relinquishes his sect. That September (1980.9.14, per some sources), the Tabernacle Temple’s remaining structure and membership are absorbed into mainstream Christianity. The Gwacheon “holy ground” is later razed for public development[s]. Yoo Jae-yeol departs Korea in October 1980 for the US, stepping out of the religious limelightshinchonjiandthebible.blogspot.com.
  • 1984: Having remained in the shadows for a few years, Lee Man-hee founds “Shincheonji” on March 14, 1984[s]. He gathers former Tabernacle members who refused the Presbyterian merger, as well as recruits from other spinoffs. He preaches that the events of Revelation (betrayal, destruction) have now happened and that Shincheonji is the promised “new heaven and new earth” (Rev 21:1) where salvation will be completed. From this point on, Shincheonji doctrine solidifies the narrative that Lee is the God-appointed successor to the failed Tabernacle Temple, having “seen and heard” its rise and fall[s][s].

Conclusion: Fact vs. Myth

Documentary evidence indicates that the Tabernacle Temple’s collapse was a real historical event, driven by very earthly problems – crime, greed, and scandal. Lee Man-hee’s break with Yoo Jae-yeol was also real: he took a stand against corruption, was physically assaulted, and left in fear for his safety[s]. Multiple sources (legal records, newspapers, and Lee’s own testimony) confirm these basic facts. There was indeed published material (newspaper articles, etc.) exposing secrets that could “bring down” the church – and ultimately did[s][s]. Lee’s knowledge of those secrets clearly made him a target, as the story suggests.

However, the embellishment comes in how the story is told within Shincheonji. The notion that Lee simply read a magazine one day and immediately feared for his life is a slight simplification of a complex sequence. Shincheonji’s official teachings do not cite a specific magazine by name, preferring to frame it as prophecy fulfillment. The group amplifies Lee’s role into that of a prophetic hero (“the Promised Pastor who overcame”), and downplays the secular fallout (fraud charges, etc.) in favor of spiritual language[s]. Korean Christian watchdogs argue that Shincheonji effectively mythologized a factual event – turning a cult collapse and a schism into a part of their theology of apostasy and new salvation[s]. In doing so, some details may be selectively presented or symbolic. For example, the “open scroll” Lee ate in 1977 could well be a metaphor for him learning of Yoo’s crimes, perhaps through an article or court document, rather than a literal heavenly scroll.

In summary: Yes, an article (or series of articles) exposing Yoo’s Tabernacle Temple did exist and played a critical role. Lee Man-hee’s own writings and Shincheonji-approved histories acknowledge that he obtained damaging information, confronted the leaders, feared for his life, and fled[s]. Independent reporting from the 1970s corroborates the specific content of that information (fraud, exploitation) and shows that the church did collapse as a result[s]. What Shincheonji adds is a theological interpretation – casting the event as a fulfillment of biblical prophecy rather than just a cult scandal. There is no indication that Shincheonji invented the entire story; on the contrary, the broad event is factual, though some narrative details (like the exact “magazine” Lee read or the exact wording of his letters) may come from Shincheonji’s internal lore, since they aren’t independently verified. Thus, this event is documented in Korean religious history, but Shincheonji’s telling certainly polishes Lee’s image. Critics maintain that Shincheonji uses this story to bolster Lee’s authority (since he “overcame” a corrupt predecessor), whereas in reality Lee was one of many who simply saw a sinking ship and jumped off. The core truth remains: Lee Man-hee saw that the Tabernacle Temple was corrupt — and whether by reading a magazine article or by witnessing it firsthand, he knew its “secrets” — and this knowledge set the stage for his dramatic exit and the birth of Shincheonji[s].

Sources

  • Dong-A Ilbo (Apr. 3, 1975), “Investigation into the new religious group ‘Tabernacle Church’” – as cited in en.wikipedia.org.
  • Introvigne, Massimo et al., The Journal of CESNUR 4(3), 2020 – Shincheonji timeline and history cesnur.net.
  • Wikipedia: “Tabernacle Temple Church” (retrieved 2024) – summary of the group’s history with references en.wikipedia.orgen.
  • Christian Analysis Blog: “History Before Shincheonji: Where was Manhee Lee?” (2010) – genealogy of Shincheonji’s rootsshinchonjiandthebible.blogspot.comshinchonjiandthebible.blogspot.com.
  • Truthaboutshincheonji.com: “Issues with Man Hee Lee and the Open Scroll” (2022) – critique of Shincheonji doctrine with excerpts from Lee’s books truthaboutshincheonji.com.
  • JoongAng Ilbo (Mar. 2020), “Gwacheon Tabernacle Temple, 18-year-old leader Yoo Jae-yeol, and Lee Man-hee’s Shincheonji” – background on Yoo and SCJ (Korean) en.wikipedia.org.
  • Kookmin Ilbo (Jan. 16, 2020), “Real reason for Tabernacle Temple’s fall? … Leader Yoo Jae-yeol jailed for fraud” (Korean) – analysis disputing Shincheonji’s version en.wikipedia.org.

The story of Lee Man-hee and Shincheonji is often framed as a triumph over the corruption of a previous era. Yet, a closer look at the history reveals an uncanny, and perhaps ironic, parallel between Lee Man-hee’s current challenges and the very scandals he once denounced in the Tabernacle Temple, led by his former spiritual leader, Yoo Jae-yeol. This reflection explores the striking similarities in allegations, leadership behavior, and the use of a “persecution” narrative by both figures, inviting a deeper understanding of accountability in religious organizations.


 

The Tabernacle Temple: A Precursor to Shincheonji’s Controversies

 

To understand the present, it’s crucial to delve into the past. Yoo Jae-yeol founded the Tabernacle Temple (장막성전) in the late 1960s, a millenarian sect that garnered significant attention. Yoo, a charismatic young figure, proclaimed himself the “young servant” who had received divine visions, quickly attracting over 2,000 followers who even relocated to a communal compound in Gwacheon, South Korea, in anticipation of an apocalyptic event prophesied for September 1969.

However, the failed doomsday prophecy in 1969 marked the beginning of the Tabernacle Temple’s unraveling. Disillusionment grew, and by the early 1970s, accusations of financial corruption and abuse began to surface. Lee Man-hee, then a devoted member, became a whistleblower, filing a lawsuit against Yoo and his leadership in 1971, alleging over 40 counts of fraud, intimidation, and other misdeeds. Lee himself claimed to have surrendered all his wealth to the group and felt utterly defrauded.

The investigations that followed painted a grim picture:

  • Fraud and Embezzlement: Yoo was found to have amassed personal wealth, including a luxurious house, by extorting forced donations and labor from his followers. Properties, farms, and even factories belonging to believers were signed over or mortgaged under false pretenses. Authorities noted an abnormally high mortality rate within the community due to harsh conditions and malnutrition.
  • Sexual Misconduct: Despite breaking from his own previous teacher over a sex scandal, Yoo and his elders were accused of sexually abusing female members under the guise of spiritual authority.
  • Abuse of Power and Intimidation: Yoo’s leadership reportedly retaliated against defectors and critics by lodging false counter-complaints with authorities, illustrating an attempt to weaponize the legal system to silence dissent. He was even charged with “false allegations” (무고).

These revelations culminated in Yoo Jae-yeol‘s arrest in September 1975 by the Seoul District Prosecutor’s Office. He was charged with fraud, embezzlement, violence, and identity theft. In 1976, Yoo was convicted of fraud and sentenced to prison, serving approximately 2.5 years. His imprisonment led to the virtual implosion of the Tabernacle Temple, with thousands of followers dispersing in disillusionment.


 

Shincheonji Under Lee Man-hee: A Reflection of the Past?

 

Decades later, Shincheonji, founded by Lee Man-hee in 1984, faces a strikingly similar array of allegations and legal challenges. This is particularly ironic given that Shincheonji’s foundational doctrine explicitly casts Yoo Jae-yeol as the “betrayer” in its narrative of “betrayal, destruction, and salvation,” a man who led the Tabernacle Temple to ruin.

Here’s a comparison of the claims and allegations:

  • Financial Misconduct: Just as Yoo was convicted of funneling church funds for personal gain, Lee Man-hee faced similar accusations. In 2020, during the height of the COVID-19 pandemic, Lee was arrested and indicted for embezzling ₩5.6 billion (approximately $4.6 million USD) of church funds. While he was acquitted of infectious disease charges, he was convicted of embezzlement and other offenses in early 2021, receiving a suspended prison sentence. This conviction directly mirrors the financial crimes for which Yoo Jae-yeol was imprisoned.
  • Abuse of Power and Sexual Misconduct: Recalling the sexual misconduct that plagued Yoo’s ministry, Lee Man-hee has also been accused of sexual exploitation. In 2024, a former senior Shincheonji instructor, Gong Hee-sook, filed a lawsuit alleging years of coerced sexual favors by Lee under the guise of spiritual authority. Shincheonji vehemently denies these claims, but the public scrutiny and the nature of the allegations draw a direct parallel to the abuses reported in the Tabernacle Temple.
  • High-Control Tactics and Secrecy: Both organizations have been described as employing high-control tactics. The Tabernacle Temple under Yoo was known for its secretive nature, intensive recruitment, and communal living, with members discouraged from outside contact. Similarly, Shincheonji is frequently labeled a “pseudo-Christian cult” that uses deceptive recruitment (e.g., members posing as ordinary students or friends to lure targets into Bible studies) and coercive control tactics like “love-bombing,” relentless schedules, sleep deprivation, and isolation from non-believers. Universities worldwide have issued warnings about Shincheonji’s infiltration tactics. In 2022, a South Korean court explicitly ruled “Shincheonji Deceptive Evangelism” as illegal, defining it as members secretly teaching doctrines while hiding their affiliation.
  • Authoritarian Rule and Dynastic Tensions: Yoo Jae-yeol was regarded as a divinely appointed figure. Lee Man-hee, too, is revered as a self-proclaimed messiah and the “victor” who overcame the corruption of the prior generation. However, just as Yoo’s absolute power led to abuses, reports have surfaced within Shincheonji of infighting over wealth and succession, with Lee’s own family members embroiled in disputes over church assets. These incidents suggest a lack of transparency and accountability, echoing the very “spiritual corruption” Lee once condemned. Recent reports from June 2025 also highlighted criticisms of Lee Man-hee for allegedly using a private convoy with sirens to control traffic and receiving preferential treatment during court-ordered legal education sessions, raising further questions about accountability and special privileges.

 

The Persecution Card: A Familiar Defense

 

Perhaps one of the most striking parallels is the consistent use of the “persecution” narrative by both Yoo Jae-yeol and Lee Man-hee to deflect criticism and avoid accountability.

When facing legal troubles and public scrutiny, Yoo Jae-yeol reportedly portrayed his predicament as being hounded as a “cult” leader to justify dissolving the Tabernacle Temple. He never admitted wrongdoing to his followers, instead framing external accusations as “satanic” attacks or lies spread by traitors. This created an “us versus them” mentality, insulating his leadership from genuine introspection.

Today, Shincheonji, which views itself as the righteous successor after Yoo’s betrayal, has adopted an eerily similar defense.

  • COVID-19 Response: During the COVID-19 outbreak, when accused of obstructing disease control efforts by withholding membership lists, Shincheonji leaders and advocates protested that the church was being scapegoated and discriminated against, rather than admitting any organizational mishandling. While Lee Man-hee was acquitted of these specific infectious disease charges by the Supreme Court in August 2022, the broader narrative of being unfairly targeted persisted.
  • Legal Challenges: Official statements from Shincheonji frequently decry “religious oppression” and accuse outsiders of unfairly targeting their rapid growth. For instance, Lee Man-hee publicly urged authorities to prevent “religious persecution” after an event was shut down due to protests from other churches, claiming rival religious groups “oppose and persecute Shincheonji…due to its rapid growth.”
  • Global Scrutiny: As investigations into Shincheonji’s activities have spread globally (e.g., arrests in Singapore, parliamentary inquiries in Australia), the church consistently frames these actions as “discrimination against a specific religion” and vows legal redress. In Singapore, investigations led to arrests of Shincheonji members in 2020 for operating an unregistered sect and using deceptive recruitment methods through front entities like “Heavenly Culture, World Peace & Restoration of Light” (HWPL).

This narrative, while designed to galvanize believers and foster loyalty, also conveniently insulates the leadership from hard questions and prevents genuine accountability. It’s a common tactic seen in various contexts, not just religious groups. For example:

  • Religious Sects: The Church of Scientology has frequently invoked “religious persecution” to dismiss fraud charges, conflating legal accountability with an attack on their faith.
  • Political Figures: Politicians investigated for corruption often cry “witch hunt” or political persecution to delegitimize the inquiry, shifting focus from their actions to an external enemy. Former Peruvian President Alan García, investigated for bribery, claimed to be a “victim of political persecution” when seeking asylum.
  • Corporate Scandals: Companies facing malpractice allegations, like Huawei when indicted for fraud, have dismissed charges as “political persecution” to avoid engaging with evidence.

As one commentator noted, “Accountability isn’t persecution.” While genuine persecution exists, the “persecution card” is often overplayed as an excuse to evade responsibility. This mindset can lead to:

  • Avoidance of Transparency: If inquiries are labeled as persecution, there’s little incentive for honest disclosure.
  • No Internal Corrections: If leaders never acknowledge faults, abuses can persist unchecked.
  • Alienating Outsiders: Consistently denying fault and blaming external forces erodes credibility with objective observers.

 

 

The scrutiny on Shincheonji continues into 2025, with specific developments in South Korea and ongoing international concerns:

South Korea:

  • Lee Jae-myung Administration’s Action on Petition (June 2025): The newly inaugurated Lee Jae-myung administration has indeed taken action on a petition filed on June 10, 2025, by an organization called “Recover” (part of the “Association for Restoring Religious Groups and Human Rights”). This petition, titled “Request for Search and Seizure of Shincheonji,” was classified as a “multi-departmental petition” by the Presidential Office. Officials have now ordered relevant ministries to conduct investigations into Shincheonji’s alleged illegal activities.
    • Recover’s Claims: The petition cites five alleged illegal activities:
      1. Sexual misconduct allegations involving Lee Man-hee and former general manager Goh Dong-an.
      2. Unfair labor practice allegations.
      3. Embezzlement allegations by Lee Man-hee and Goh Dong-an.
      4. Illegal receipt of unemployment benefits by members from Shincheonji Peter tribe, where followers were reportedly used as disguised labor to fraudulently obtain unemployment pay and health insurance during a four-year construction of a headquarters building. The Ministry of Employment and Labor, specifically its Gwangju branch, is investigating this.
      5. Allegations of wage violation related to monthly payments (₩300,000–₩500,000) made to full-time Shincheonji workers, potentially below minimum wage.
    • Recover asserts that Shincheonji operates not as a legitimate religious entity but as an “illegal multi-level organization” exploiting followers for labor and monetary gain. This swift response from the new administration, which took action within a week of the petition, marks a significant development in the ongoing legal oversight of Shincheonji in South Korea.
  • Ongoing Criticisms of Lee Man-hee’s Conduct (June 2025): Recent reports from The Korea Herald and JTBC in late June 2025 revealed new allegations regarding Lee Man-hee’s conduct. These include:
    • Illegal Private Convoy: Lee Man-hee is accused of using a private convoy of Shincheonji members on motorcycles, equipped with red and blue sirens, to control traffic and clear his path. These individuals have no legal authority to do so, and such use of sirens is illegal under South Korean road traffic laws. This practice reportedly began after Lee experienced police escort services during a visit to the Philippines in 2016.
    • Preferential Treatment in Court-Ordered Education: Following his 2021 conviction for embezzlement and obstruction of business, Lee was ordered to complete 80 hours of “legal compliance education.” However, he allegedly received all 16 sessions one-on-one in a separate room with a foldable bed, taught by a regular staff member of the Legal Compliance Support Center, not a professional instructor. This stands in contrast to the typical group classroom setting for such education. The Ministry of Justice cited Lee’s old age and health issues as reasons for the arrangement, but critics have labeled it “royal education.”
  • Political Influence Allegations: Although a 2020 prosecutor’s ruling found no evidence linking Lee to the creation of the former Liberty Korea Party, Shincheonji has faced ongoing accusations of attempting to exert political influence, including leaked chatroom conversations showing opposition to a specific candidate in South Korea’s 2022 presidential election.

International Investigations:

  • Singapore (Ongoing): As noted, Singaporean authorities arrested 21 Shincheonji members in 2020 for operating an unregistered sect and using deceptive recruitment methods. Investigations into its front entities and controlling influence over young members continue.
  • Australia (Ongoing Inquiry): A Victorian parliamentary inquiry in Australia, launched in 2025, continues to probe coercive cults like Shincheonji. This inquiry invites testimony on deceptive recruitment, psychological abuse, and harm to members, with ex-members speaking out in Parliament and the media about Shincheonji’s tactics of discouraging outside contact and exploiting young people through front groups.

 

Theological Reinterpretation: The Omission of History

 

Shincheonji’s own theology of “betrayal, destruction, and salvation” is a direct reinterpretation of the Tabernacle Temple’s downfall. In this narrative, Yoo Jae-yeol is explicitly cast as the “betrayer” whose corruption led to the “first heaven” (the Tabernacle Temple) breaking its covenant with God. The “destruction” is attributed to Pastor Oh Pyeong-ho and the Presbyterian Church merging with the Tabernacle Temple, described as “destroyers” or “Nicolaitans” who invaded the spiritually bankrupt church. Finally, “salvation” comes through Lee Man-hee, the “one who overcomes” who was commissioned by Jesus to establish Shincheonji as the true Tabernacle of the Testimony.

However, a crucial omission in this narrative is Lee Man-hee’s own direct role in bringing down Yoo Jae-yeol through legal action. While the narrative acknowledges Yoo’s corruption, it downplays or omits that it was Lee’s whistleblower lawsuit that directly led to Yoo’s arrest and the Tabernacle Temple’s collapse. This omission is significant because acknowledging Lee’s active role in “destroying” the previous tabernacle would contradict his prophesied role as the pure “overcomer” who brings salvation, rather than contributing to destruction. The historical evidence, including police reports and news archives from the 1970s, clearly demonstrates Lee Man-hee’s pivotal role in exposing Yoo’s crimes.


 

Conclusion: The Ironic Repetition of History

 

The parallels between Yoo Jae-yeol‘s Tabernacle Temple and Lee Man-hee’s Shincheonji are not merely coincidental; they represent a striking and profound irony. Lee Man-hee rose to prominence by championing himself as one who overcame a corrupt religious leader, taking legal action and blowing the whistle on the very issues of financial misconduct and abuse that plagued Yoo Jae-yeol. He feared for his life and endured bad treatments, ultimately bringing down his former spiritual leader who ended up in prison. Yet, in a cruel twist of fate, Lee Man-hee now finds himself facing investigations and allegations that mirror those once leveled against Mr. Yoo.

The script has truly flipped. The very “persecution card” that Yoo Jae-yeol employed to deflect from accountability, now appears to be a go-to defense for Lee Man-hee and Shincheonji, as they face accusations of embezzlement, sexual abuse, deceptive practices, and lack of transparency. The emphasis on “spiritual attacks” and “persecution” serves to look down on testimonies that go against Shincheonji’s approved narrative, much like Mr. Yoo dismissed Lee Man-hee’s legitimate concerns as a “threat.”

This pattern is clear: “Accountability isn’t persecution.” While genuine persecution exists, the overreliance on this narrative by both Yoo and now Lee, creates an echo chamber that shields leaders from vital introspection and necessary reform. The fact that Shincheonji’s own foundational theology omits the historical reality of Lee Man-hee’s role in bringing down Yoo Jae-yeol, presenting Yoo’s corruption as an unexplained “betrayal” without detailing the legal and whistleblowing efforts that exposed it, is a stark example of controlling the narrative to fit a predetermined “savior” role.

This mirror-like repetition of history offers a sobering reflection point for observers and, perhaps most importantly, for Shincheonji members themselves. It prompts questions:

  • Is Shincheonji inadvertently following in the footsteps of the very group it claims to have surpassed?
  • By dismissing every controversy as “persecution,” is Shincheonji avoiding genuine accountability and transparency, much as Mr. Yoo’s group did when it blamed “outsiders” for its demise?

The Bible itself provides numerous examples of leaders and communities being called to account for their actions, even by God, and not every rebuke is an “attack from Satan.” For instance, in Revelation 2-3, Jesus directly addresses various churches, commending their strengths but also critiquing their failings and calling them to repentance. This biblical precedent suggests that self-reflection and acknowledging shortcomings are vital for spiritual health and integrity.

True leadership, whether religious or secular, is built on humility and responsibility, not divine immunity. Healthy organizations do not fear accountability; they welcome it as a means to improve. Conversely, unhealthy groups reflexively treat accountability as an attack. Breaking out of a persecution mindset does not mean abandoning one’s faith; rather, it means exercising discernment and humility, encouraging questions, being transparent with information, and taking valid criticism seriously.

The story of Lee Man-hee and Yoo Jae-yeol stands as a powerful reminder that history can, and often does, repeat itself if lessons are not genuinely learned. The integrity of any community is measured by how it responds when confronted with wrongdoing or error – whether it chooses reform and truth, or doubles down on denial and blame. The profound irony is that Lee Man-hee, who once championed accountability against his corrupt leader, now faces the same accusations and employs the same defense mechanism, echoing the very cycle he once fought to break.

Related Story:

1. Scandals of Mr Yoo Jr,: Mentor-Turned-Traitor in SCJ’s Origin Story

2. Reality of the Fulfillment of Revelation – Chapter 1


 

Sources:

 

A Full Explanation with Figurative Meaning

According to Shincheonji (SCJ) theology, Lee Man-hee is believed to be the only person who has seen and heard the fulfillment of the entire Book of Revelation. For that reason, he is said to fulfill numerous symbolic identities and receive all the blessings promised in Scripture to those who overcome. These identities are not considered separate roles held by different people, but titles and functions fulfilled by one man at the time of the Second Coming. Below is a comprehensive list of these roles, with detailed explanations of their spiritual and figurative meanings, as interpreted by SCJ.

These roles are not randomly assigned. In SCJ teaching, they are interconnected through parables, each one figuratively pointing to a specific role the Promised Pastor would fulfill at the time of Revelation’s fulfillment. The parables of Jesus are seen as sealed prophecies which only the one who receives the open scroll (Rev 10) can reveal in actual reality.

  • The Promised Pastor: Lee is described as the one chosen by God and Jesus to testify to the physical fulfillment of Revelation. He is seen as the shepherd promised in prophecy, just like Moses was promised before the Exodus, or Jesus before the First Coming. According to SCJ, the Bible is a book of promises, and every era had a “promised pastor.” The Promised Pastor in the time of Revelation comes not to predict, but to testify what has been fulfilled (Rev 22:8, 16). He is the center of salvation at the time of the end.
  • The One Who Overcomes (Rev 2–3): The seven promises given to the one who overcomes are considered figurative blessings representing spiritual authority:
    • Tree of Life: Eternal life through the Word
    • Crown of Life: Victory and kingship
    • Hidden Manna & White Stone: Secret Word and authority to judge
    • Iron Scepter: Spiritual rule over nations
    • New Name: Identity united with Jesus
    • Pillar: Permanent place in God’s dwelling
    • Sit on Jesus’ Throne: Share in Christ’s ruling authority
  • In parables, overcoming is linked to the wise servant who endures persecution (Matt 24:13), the good soil that bears fruit (Matt 13), and the sheep that follow the true shepherd (John 10). Overcoming means resisting falsehood and holding to the truth.

    SCJ teaches that to overcome means to defeat the group of the dragon—the Stewardship Education Center (SEC)—that invaded and corrupted the Tabernacle Temple. By doing this, Lee restored spiritual order and fulfilled Revelation 12:11, thus becoming the New Spiritual Israel. Just as Jacob’s name became Israel after wrestling and overcoming, Lee is also symbolically the new Israel. He becomes the head of a new spiritual nation made up of 12 Tribes, like the 12 sons of Jacob. These tribes are organized as Shincheonji’s Twelve Tribes, which form the kingdom of heaven on earth.

    Furthermore, SCJ parallels Lee’s task to that of Moses. Just as Moses saw the heavenly tabernacle and was commanded to build it on earth (Exodus 25:9), Lee is believed to have seen the fulfillment of heaven and was commanded to build the same on earth. That structure is Shincheonji—the new heaven and new earth. Ultimately, at the Wedding Banquet of the Lamb (Rev 19), the heavenly New Jerusalem will spiritually descend and unite with this earthly temple, fulfilling “on earth as it is in heaven.” Through this union of spirit (heaven) and flesh (earth), eternal life is made possible.
  • The Faithful and Wise Servant (Matt 24:45): The parable of the wise servant shows that God assigns someone to distribute “food at the proper time.” SCJ explains this food as the revealed Word. The Promised Pastor distributes this spiritual food—the open scroll (Rev 10)—to the saints who are waiting. Without it, no one can understand Revelation.
  • The Male Child (Rev 12:5): The woman clothed with the sun (symbolizing the Tabernacle Temple) gives birth to a male child. The male child overcomes the dragon and is caught up to God. In parable form, this means that someone born of God’s chosen place escapes Satan’s deception and receives authority. In real life, SCJ teaches this male child is Lee Man-hee.
  • The White Horse Jesus Rides (Rev 19:11): In parable language, horses often symbolize flesh (physical people). Jesus rides a white horse, meaning a clean, pure person through whom he works. The horse is not Jesus but is used by him. SCJ believes Lee is this “white horse,” the visible body that Jesus uses to fight spiritual war with the Word.
  • The Iron Scepter (Rev 2:27, 12:5): The iron scepter is not a literal object, but a symbol of the authority of God’s Word, with which one can rule and judge. Parables compare this to a shepherd’s staff, which guides and disciplines the flock (Ps 23:4). Lee is said to possess this authority.
  • The Open Scroll and Measuring Rod (Rev 10 & 11): Eating the scroll is likened to the Word becoming part of a person. In Ezekiel 3 and Revelation 10, this action signifies complete understanding of the prophecy. The measuring rod in Rev 11 represents the standard of judgment, i.e., the Word. The one who eats the scroll uses the Word to measure the people—symbolizing judgment and selection.
  • The Bride of Christ (Rev 19, 21): Parables such as the ten virgins (Matt 25) and the wedding banquet (Matt 22) speak of the union of spirit and flesh. In SCJ, Jesus is the groom and the spirit, and Lee Man-hee is the chosen flesh, the vessel prepared to unite with the Spirit. Through this union, salvation is given.
  • The Tree of Life (Rev 22:1–2): This tree bears fruit every month and its leaves are for healing. Figuratively, it represents a source of spiritual life—someone who gives eternal life through God’s revealed Word. In SCJ, this is Lee. Just as Jesus was considered the Tree of Life in his era, Lee is believed to fulfill this role in the era of the Second Coming. SCJ teaches that the Tree of Life is symbolic of the one who possesses and delivers the Word of life. Since Lee has received the open scroll, he provides the food that brings spiritual healing and eternal life. Furthermore, since the Tree of Life is located in the paradise of God, SCJ understands it to also symbolize the place where God dwells. Therefore, in this era, being united with the Tree of Life—Lee Man-hee—is like entering the kingdom of heaven itself, because God, Jesus, and the Word are said to be with him.
  • The Two Witnesses (Rev 11): These two are not literal but symbolic of two people who testify together. SCJ teaches that this was fulfilled through Lee and Hong Jong-hyo, who together testified during the destruction of the Tabernacle Temple. Their “death” and “resurrection” are symbolic of rejection and vindication, linked to the parables of the stone the builders rejected (Matt 21:42).
  • The Oil Seller (Matt 25:9): The five wise virgins had oil, and the foolish did not. Oil here is interpreted as the revealed Word. The seller is the one who possesses understanding. Lee, in this parable, is the one from whom the saints must receive spiritual oil to be saved.
  • The Morning Star (Rev 2:28): This symbolizes the spirit of Jesus that dwells with the overcomer. Just as the day star brings light after darkness, Lee is seen as the one bringing spiritual dawn.
  • New John (Rev 10, 22:16): Just as the apostle John received and wrote Revelation, New John is the actual fulfillment—not the writer of prophecy, but the one who sees it all come true and testifies to it. This role connects to the parables of the messenger, the sower, and the seed-bearing fruit (Matt 13).

All these parables—of brides and virgins, wise servants, trees and fruit, shepherds and sheep—are understood by SCJ to be figurative teachings pointing to one central reality: the appearance of a Promised Pastor who would unite the Word and spirit, overcome deception, and testify to the fulfillment of Revelation. In their view, this person is Lee Man-hee. The parables are fulfilled in his life, testimony, and the establishment of the Twelve Tribes of Shincheonji.

To reject this testimony, according to SCJ, is to reject Jesus who sent him, just as Jesus said in John 13:20.

Please take the time to check the Bible verses we’ve provided as references. Use them as a guide for your own understanding and discernment. It’s important to verify and confirm information with external sources, witnesses, and experts to ensure validity and transparency. Additionally, remember to pray for wisdom as you seek to identify any errors and ensure that your understanding aligns with biblical teachings.

Let's assess whether SCJ's interpretation aligns with biblical teachings in context

Context or Contradiction?

You may also like

You cannot copy content of this page