Introduction
The visions in Revelation use symbolic images that function as unified composites, where each element contributes to a single meaning rather than representing separate beings or independent agents. This is a standard feature of apocalyptic literature. When John shows a rider on a horse, he is not describing two different entities working together, but one symbolic image expressing a single theological reality. Just as Daniel’s beasts, the woman in Revelation 12, or the Lamb in Revelation 5 are composite figures that operate as integrated symbols, the horse and rider in Revelation 6 communicate one unified concept: the advance of divine judgment at the command of the Lamb.
This background is essential because Shincheonji’s interpretation separates the rider from the horse and assigns each an independent symbolic identity. They claim that the rider represents a spirit and the horse represents a physical human body used by that spirit. This approach depends on dividing what apocalyptic literature consistently treats as one symbolic unit. Before examining why this separation fails, it is important to establish how composite imagery works in biblical visions and why Revelation’s presentation of the horse and rider cannot be broken into a “spirit through flesh” equation.
Be aware that groups like Shincheonji often respond to criticism by subtly adjusting their doctrine—a common tactic involving denial, adaptation, and manipulation; is a common tactic among high-control organizations. They may gather information on critics and “flip the script,” portraying exposure as persecution or misinformation. It’s essential to carefully observe doctrinal shifts rather than accepting new explanations at face value. Stay vigilant against gaslighting through evolving teachings designed to counter today’s realities and criticisms. (Read More)
The Composite Image of the Rider and the Horse
Shincheonji’s Perspective
Shincheonji breaks down the image of the horse and rider by separating what the text presents as a single symbolic figure into two distinct components, assigning each a different theological role. They argue that the rider represents a spirit and the horse represents a physical body that the spirit uses, turning the unified apocalyptic image into a mechanism for their doctrine of “spirit working through flesh.” In this framework, every detail in the vision is split apart: the rider becomes a divine or angelic spirit, the horse becomes the flesh of a human vessel, and the motion of the horse is treated as the obedience of that vessel to the spirit that “rides” it. This interpretive move imports a dualistic system into the text that Revelation never suggests, fractures the composite nature of apocalyptic symbolism, and ultimately recasts the first seal as a description of a human mediator rather than a heavenly judgment issued at the command of the Lamb.
Doctrinal Issues
The Biblical Pattern: Christ Works Through the Church, Not Through One Man
SCJ’s appeal to “spirit working through flesh” also ignores the consistent biblical pattern of how Christ exercises His authority after His resurrection and ascension. Across the New Testament, Jesus does not select one human being as the exclusive vessel of divine revelation or the sole mediator of His will. Instead, He works through a community of redeemed people—first the Twelve apostles, then the broader church formed by His Spirit. This unified pattern stands in direct tension with SCJ’s claim that the rider on the white horse symbolizes one specially chosen “promised pastor” through whom all spiritual authority flows.
Jesus Works Through the Twelve, Not a Single Successor
During His earthly ministry, Jesus appointed twelve apostles, not one successor, and He distributed authority, revelation, and mission among them as a collective body. The Twelve received:
-
the authority to preach and drive out demons (Mark 3:14–15)
-
the power to heal (Matthew 10:1)
-
the responsibility of teaching and testifying to Christ (John 15:27)
-
the commission to make disciples of every nation (Matthew 28:18–20)
Jesus could have chosen a single authoritative successor if that had been His design, but He did not. He created a plural leadership structure—twelve witnesses—precisely to prevent the concentration of divine authority in a single post-Jesus figure.
This stands opposite to SCJ’s framework, where all interpretation, revelation, and access to God allegedly flow through one Korean man.
Jesus Works Through the Whole Church—His Body and His Bride
After His ascension, Jesus’ ongoing work is never channeled through one prophet, pastor, or “one who overcomes.” Instead, Scripture emphasizes that Christ acts through His entire church, which He calls His:
-
Body (1 Corinthians 12:12–27)
-
Bride (Ephesians 5:25–27; Revelation 19:7–8)
-
Holy Priesthood (1 Peter 2:5)
-
Temple of the Spirit (Ephesians 2:19–22)
Every believer receives the Spirit (1 Corinthians 12:13). Every member is gifted for the common good (1 Corinthians 12:7). Every part of the body contributes to the mission and revelation of Christ. The apostolic church is never depicted as a single “horse” ridden by a single “spirit-contained pastor,” but as a multi-membered organism animated directly by Christ Himself.
Revelation Continues This Pattern
Even in the book of Revelation itself, Christ communicates not to one specially chosen interpreter, but to:
-
the seven churches
-
through seven angels
-
by seven messages
-
using seven lampstands
The symbolism is intentionally corporate, not individualistic.
When Christ addresses the churches, every promise to “the one who overcomes” is addressed to the entire community of believers, not to a singular prophetic figure who stands at the top of a hierarchy (Revelation 2–3). The overcomers are the saints, not a solitary pastor.
SCJ’s interpretation requires proving two things: that God normally selects one person as His exclusive vessel, and that Revelation 6 is describing that kind of relationship. Yet the biblical pattern shows the opposite. Jesus never appoints a solitary promised pastor, the Spirit is poured out on all believers, and the apostles function collectively rather than as a hierarchy leading toward one final mediator. Christ continues to work through His entire church as His body, not through a single chosen individual who becomes the channel of all revelation.
Is there a Promised Pastor of the New Testament?
When this pattern is taken seriously, the attempt to insert Lee Man-hee into the image of the rider on the white horse collapses. The idea that the horse represents flesh used by a spirit contradicts the New Testament model of corporate life and shared mission among believers. It also contradicts the consistent way God acts after the ascension, where His Word and Spirit operate within the community of faith rather than through one exclusive human representative.
Within this wider biblical framework, the white horse and its rider in Revelation fit naturally as a single heavenly agent of judgment. Revelation repeatedly shows heavenly messengers acting at the Lamb’s command, judgments originating from heaven, and symbolic visions portraying divine authority extending into the world. At the same time, the book presents the church as a plural people who witness, suffer, and overcome together. Nowhere does Revelation or any New Testament writing depict Christ channeling all authority or interpretation through one person. To claim otherwise is to reshape the biblical narrative around the life story of a single individual.
No Textual Warrant
John gives no indication anywhere in the text that the rider and the horse are two separate beings or that one is acting as a vessel for the other. The vision presents a single, unified figure in motion: “he went out conquering and to conquer” (Revelation 6:2). The grammatical structure reinforces this unity. Every action in the passage—receiving the crown, going out, conquering—is attributed solely to the rider. The horse is never given an independent verb, role, or consciousness. It functions as part of the imagery of movement and authority, not as an agent in its own right.
In apocalyptic writing, such details are not arbitrary; authors like John use symbolic composites deliberately. Just as “the beast with ten horns” in Daniel or “the woman clothed with the sun” in Revelation 12 form single, integrated images, the “horse and rider” in Revelation 6 describe one operative symbol: the advance of divine judgment. To read two agents—a spirit using a fleshly vessel—into this vision is to import a foreign framework absent from the text itself. Nothing in Revelation 6 suggests that the horse possesses its own identity, personality, or will distinct from the rider. It is a visual extension of the rider’s power and mission, much like the chariot of a conquering king, emphasizing unstoppable motion and divine command.
Genre Rule
In apocalyptic literature, symbolic pairs such as lion and lamb, beast and horns, or lampstand and lamp are never meant to be interpreted as two distinct beings acting separately. Instead, they function as composite images—interdependent parts of one unified symbol that conveys a single theological truth. Each component adds nuance or emphasis to the whole but does not represent a separate entity or consciousness.
The same interpretive rule applies to the horse and rider imagery in Revelation 6. Within the visionary genre, this pair forms a single apocalyptic icon symbolizing divine authority in motion. The horse represents the energy, speed, and unstoppable advance of judgment, while the rider embodies the purpose and control behind that movement. Together, they depict one composite agent of heavenly power sent forth at the command of the Lamb. Reading the horse and rider as two beings—spirit and flesh—ignores the literary conventions of visionary symbolism and fractures a unified image that John clearly intends to function as one.
The Vision Is Symbolic, Not Mechanistic
Revelation’s imagery presents heavenly agency, not the mechanics of spiritual possession. The horse and its rider are symbolic representations of divine authority in motion, visualizing God’s will being executed on earth through heavenly command. They are not descriptions of how spirits inhabit or work through physical bodies. Apocalyptic symbols function theologically and poetically, not anatomically. Their purpose is to reveal God’s sovereignty and the unfolding of His judgments, not to provide a technical diagram of spirit–flesh interaction. To interpret the “rider and horse” as a model of angelic or divine possession reduces the genre’s vivid symbolism to literal mechanics and turns prophetic poetry into a manual for metaphysics—a fundamental misreading of apocalyptic literature.
No Textual Indication of Humans
Revelation 6 contains no textual evidence that either the horses or their riders symbolize human beings. Each rider appears only after the Lamb opens a seal, and each responds to the summons of one of the four living creatures who cry out from heaven, “Come!” This clearly situated the scene within the heavenly court, not the earthly realm. The horses and riders emerge as agents of divine judgment, sent forth in obedience to the Lamb’s command. The passage never hints that these figures enter, possess, or operate through human flesh. Their origin, authority, and activity are entirely heavenly, functioning as symbolic manifestations of God’s sovereign power rather than representations of human participants in the vision.
Contextual Contrast
The four horsemen in Revelation 6 intentionally parallel the four spirits of heaven described in Zechariah 6. In Zechariah’s vision, the colored horses represent divine forces sent out by God to patrol the earth, symbolizing His sovereignty and control over the nations. These horses are explicitly called “the four spirits of heaven”—heavenly agents carrying out God’s will, not people or physical vessels. John’s vision follows the same prophetic pattern. The horses and riders in Revelation 6 likewise emerge at the Lamb’s command, signifying judgments dispatched from heaven. Nothing in either context suggests the imagery refers to spirits entering human bodies. Instead, both visions portray the same theological reality: God’s authority extending from heaven to earth through His appointed heavenly messengers.
Genre Consistency
Each of the seal judgments in Revelation 6 operates within the same symbolic framework. The red horse represents war and bloodshed, the black horse represents famine and economic collapse, and the pale horse represents death and Hades. These images are not literal descriptions of people or events but symbolic portrayals of divine judgments unleashed upon the world. To interpret the first seal differently—treating the white horse as a literal human used by a spirit while keeping the other horses symbolic—creates a clear inconsistency within the vision’s structure. John presents all four horsemen as a cohesive sequence of heavenly agents acting at the Lamb’s command, each corresponding to a distinct aspect of divine judgment. The genre of apocalyptic vision requires internal unity: either all four are symbolic, or none are. Reading the first as literal “spirit through flesh” while reading the others symbolically violates the internal logic and literary consistency of the passage.
SCJ’s model merges two very different biblical categories:
| Biblical Concept | Description | Example |
| Indwelling of the Holy Spirit | Permanent, sanctifying presence within all believers. | John 14:17; 1 Cor 3:16 |
| Prophetic inspiration | Temporary empowerment for revelation or mission. | 2 Pet 1:21; Acts 2:4 |
| Demonic or angelic possession | Control over a person’s body and speech. | Mark 5:2–8 (demonic case) |
The Bible never presents angelic possession of human flesh as a normal or holy means of revelation.
Prophets spoke as they were moved by the Spirit — but they remained fully conscious and morally responsible.
The Spirit does not use people as animals to be ridden, but indwells and guides them as persons made in God’s image.
Even granting their premise, SCJ’s interpretation still collapses under its own logic:
| SCJ Premise | Resulting Contradiction |
| Angels use flesh to carry out God’s judgment. | The horses in Revelation 6 are already heavenly spirits; there’s no need for them to “borrow” flesh. |
| The white horse = the flesh used by angels. | But the other three horses (red, black, pale) must also be “flesh used by angels”—which makes “Death and Hades” human too, an absurd conclusion (6:8). |
| Revelation 6 is fulfilled through people, not spiritual visions. | The scene unfolds in heaven before the throne, not on earth; the initiative is entirely divine. |
| God’s will requires a physical mediator. | Revelation consistently portrays divine agency from heaven, not from human vessels. (e.g., Rev 8:2–6; 15:1) |
So even under the “angels working through flesh” model, the interpretation contradicts the text’s own spatial and theological framework.
The Biblical Principle of Divine Agency
Throughout Scripture, God’s actions are mediated through His Word and His Spirit, not through the possession of human bodies. The biblical pattern emphasizes divine authority expressed by command, not by incarnation repeated in others.
God’s Word Itself Is His Agent
God accomplishes His purposes by speaking, not by borrowing flesh. Psalm 33:9 declares, “He spoke, and it came to be,” revealing that creation and command flow directly from His Word. Isaiah 55:11 affirms, “So shall My word be… it shall accomplish that which I purpose,” showing that His Word carries its own power to fulfill His will. Hebrews 4:12 describes the Word of God as “living and active,” penetrating creation and the human heart without needing a physical intermediary. In Revelation, this same Word is personified in Christ, from whose mouth proceeds the sharp sword that enacts judgment (Revelation 19:15). The Word itself executes divine will; Christ does not require another human vessel to carry it out.
Angels Are Messengers, Not Possessors
Scripture also shows that angels function as servants and heralds of God’s commands, not as spirits that inhabit human bodies. Hebrews 1:14 calls them “ministering spirits sent out to serve for the sake of those who are to inherit salvation.” They deliver messages, announce judgments, and protect God’s people, but they never operate by overtaking human flesh. Nowhere in the New Testament are angels described as “riding” or “using” people to perform their tasks. The consistent biblical model is one of obedience and cooperation, where humans respond to divine instruction, not one of possession or control, where spirits commandeer human agents.
This distinction preserves the transcendence and sovereignty of God. His power works through command and Word, not through dependency on a human host. The heavenly agents in Revelation act according to this same principle—they obey the Lamb’s command from heaven, demonstrating divine authority, not incarnation.
Reintegrating This into the Composite Imagery
If we return to the composite nature of the white horse, the SCJ model simply doesn’t fit:
| Element | SCJ’s Reading | Composite Symbol Reading |
| Rider | Angelic or divine spirit | Single agent of heavenly conquest |
| Horse | Human flesh used by spirit | Symbol of power and movement |
| Action (“went out conquering”) | Spirit working through people | Divine decree proceeding into history |
| Scene Setting | Fulfillment through human cooperation | Vision in heaven, not earth |
By imposing their angelic model, SCJ turns the visionary symbol into a doctrinal diagram—a misuse of apocalyptic language.
John’s vision wasn’t describing how angels operate through humans, but how the Lamb’s authority unleashes events that affect the world.
The Theological Core
The point of the first seal isn’t how God uses people, but who controls history.
The Lamb’s act of opening the seals shows that all conquest, deception, and judgment occur under Christ’s command, whether through angelic or earthly means.
The vision reveals heaven’s initiative, not earth’s cooperation.
That’s why the voice says, “Come!”—not “Go possess flesh.”
The movement is downward—from heaven’s command to earth’s consequence.
The point of the first seal is not to explain how God uses people but to reveal who controls history. The focus of the vision rests entirely on the Lamb, whose act of opening the seals initiates every event that follows. Each rider goes forth only after Christ’s command, demonstrating that every form of conquest, deception, and judgment unfolds under His sovereign authority. The emphasis lies on heaven’s initiative, not human cooperation. When the living creature cries, “Come!” it is a summons issued from the heavenly realm, not an instruction to inhabit human flesh. The motion of the entire vision is from heaven downward—from the Lamb’s decree to the unfolding of consequences on earth. Revelation 6 therefore exalts Christ as the one who governs history and releases judgment, not as a spirit seeking a body through which to act.
Expected Pushback
SCJ may claim that their model is not possession but a form of divine cooperation. Yet the biblical comparison with the Holy Spirit exposes how foreign their framework is. When the Holy Spirit indwells believers, He does not override their identity or use their bodies as instruments to perform His own actions. Instead, He transforms, guides, and empowers them as full, conscious participants who remain morally responsible. Believers speak, think, and act as renewed people, not as passive carriers of a heavenly spirit riding them. The Spirit produces fruit by shaping character, not by commandeering flesh. This stands in sharp contrast to SCJ’s “spirit through flesh” model, where the human becomes the functional body of a heavenly spirit’s activity. Scripture never describes the Spirit using a person as a mode of movement or a tool for enactment. The Spirit dwells in believers as persons created in God’s image, while SCJ’s model treats the human as a vehicle to be steered. This comparison makes clear that SCJ’s framework is neither biblical nor consistent with how God’s own Spirit operates within His people.
Do Angels need a human co-host to carry out God’s will?
Scripture consistently portrays angels carrying out God’s judgments directly, without inhabiting or operating through human bodies. In Genesis 19, the angels who visit Sodom execute judgment themselves by striking the men of the city with blindness and later delivering the warning of destruction. In 2 Samuel 24 and 1 Chronicles 21, the destroying angel stretches out his hand over Jerusalem, bringing plague until God commands him to stop. In Isaiah 37 and 2 Kings 19, the angel of the Lord strikes down one hundred eighty-five thousand Assyrian soldiers in a single night. In the Passover narrative of Exodus 12, the destroyer moves through Egypt to carry out God’s decree without any human intermediary. And in Revelation itself, angels trumpet judgments, pour out bowls of wrath, restrain winds, open pits, bind Satan, and deliver plagues, all acting by direct command from heaven. None of these scenes involve angels borrowing human flesh or riding a human “horse.” The consistent biblical pattern is that angels execute God’s will as angels, not through the bodies of human beings.
Conclusion
One Vision, Four Faces of Divine Judgment
Revelation 6:1-8 presents a single, coherent vision.
Each horse and rider symbolizes a facet of the judgments the Lamb unleashes when He opens the first four seals:
| Color | Description | Symbolic Function | Scriptural Parallels |
| White (6:1-2) | Conquest—authorized advance from heaven | The going-forth of power under divine sovereignty—whether gospel triumph or permitted deception | Zech 6:1-8; Rev 19:11-16 |
| Red (6:3-4) | War and bloodshed | Removal of peace from the earth | Matt 24:6-7 |
| Black (6:5-6) | Famine and economic imbalance | Scarcity and injustice under judgment | Lev 26:26; Amos 8:11 |
| Pale (6:7-8) | Death and Hades | The culmination of divine wrath—mortality itself | Ezek 14:21 |
The four horses mirror Zechariah’s four chariots—spirits of heaven sent out at God’s command.
They form a unified sequence of divine activity, not four episodes of human participation.
- Why does John suddenly switch to literal martyrdom in Seal 5?
- Why does the same Greek word stop meaning “spiritual death” and suddenly mean “physical death”?
- Why does John not mark the shift with symbolic language?
- Why does SCJ remove Revelation’s natural connection to Ezekiel’s four judgments?
- How can the martyrs cry out for vengeance if they were “spiritually” killed?
Why SCJ’s “Spirit-Through-Flesh” Reading Fails for All Four
Consistency Problem
If the white horse represents “pure flesh used by angels,” then by consistency the red, black, and pale horses must also represent “flesh used by angels,” including the final rider named Death (6:8). Such an interpretation quickly becomes untenable and even absurd, forcing a theological contradiction in which divine judgment would require multiple incarnations.
Heavenly Origin
Each horse appears directly from heaven at the Lamb’s command. The living creature calls out “Come!” and the horse and rider emerge in response. None originate from the earth, human history, or human activity. The imagery points upward to divine initiative, not downward to human participation.
Genre Integrity
The vision belongs to the genre of apocalyptic revelation, not parable. Its symbols function as heavenly depictions of decreed outcomes, not coded descriptions of how angels or spirits operate through human beings. The horses represent divine forces released by the Lamb’s authority, not methods of embodiment.
Theological Focus
The repeated phrase “it was given to him…” makes clear that all power and permission flow from Christ, the Lamb who opens the seals. The authority of the horsemen derives entirely from Him, not from any human intermediary or vessel.
Taken together, these features expose the incompatibility of SCJ’s reading with the text itself. To impose the “spirit using flesh” model on this passage would dismantle its literary coherence and distort its central message: the Lamb alone governs the unfolding of history and the execution of divine judgment.
The Composite Meanings of the Four Horses
Together the horses portray the progressive unfolding of divine sovereignty:
- The white horse—Heaven’s decree of conquest, whether salvific or judicial.
- The red horse—Violence unleashed as consequence of rebellion.
- The black horse—Economic and moral imbalance under divine measure.
- The pale horse—The inevitability of death under sin’s curse.
Each operates as a heavenly emissary, demonstrating that all earthly events—triumph, war, famine, and death—are ultimately under the Lamb’s command.
The imagery is not about heaven needing human flesh to act, but about heaven governing history through its own authority.
Across all four seals, the consistent subject is not “the spirits and the flesh they use,” but the Lamb Himself:
- He opens every seal.
- He authorizes every rider.
- He controls every phase of judgment.
The purpose of the vision is to reveal Christ’s dominion, not to outline a mechanism of revelation through chosen humans.